Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy McGuffey Casual Slip-on Sneaker

They are fine.

Very good. Love the product. Would have been five stars but noticed the amount of time between when the product was ready to ship vs. when it was actually in transit. Figured this was because I didn't opt for the premium delivery option.

A great comfortable casual shoe. I'm starting to order more J&M shoes because I'm finding the comfort level is better than most.

Great look and feel. It did run a little big however.

Im very happy with your products

I really like the McGuffey slip-on. The shoe was comfortable and good quality. The shoe was too narrow for my foot. It rubbed my little toe. If it was not for that I would have loved the shoes.

I gave it 4 stars because over the past several years the quality and consistency of the shoes has gone down. I have had to replace not only shoes but belts much faster than in the past due to issues with construction of the product or just defects in the materials etc.

The shoes are very comfortable but socks are necessary as they will cause blisters on the ankles

When will the blues be available in 15 W

Very Comfortable pair of casual shoes. Love the arch support.

Good

I have found that a good and comfortable shoe is in the insole. Is there an insole, is it within the footbed, is it too hard, is it to thin, is there enough cushioning for the insole to rest comfortably. Next thing does it align to the foot when walking or does it cantal to one sign thus throwing the foot off balance. Next is how does it wear with the days clothing. Is it stylish, out of place, an eye sore. I have found that the McGuffey shoes are A+ in my book

I love this shoe. I was really excited to wear them. This was my 3 different slip on purchase. However, after slight wear (less than a month) the weaves we're starting to expand and you could see my socks. J&M replaced the shoe for me, I just went with a different McGuffey slip on.

Color appeared lighter on the website. When it came it was much darker than it appeared on line.

I have a narrower foot; feels a bit loose.

Comfortable, I like the way it feels. Gets dirty a little easy so I have to be careful. Overall love it, going to buy the blue one.

These McGuffey slip-ons have the most comfortable fit and the best cushioning among all the J&M shoes I've purchased over the years. My only gripe is that the shoe could have been made with slightly thicker leather and the leather lining could have been more extensive. Hence, the 4* instead of 5*.

Nice looking shoe, but too long! The shoe was comfortable in my size, but the elongated look of the extra 1-1/4" of the shoe was not appealing to my eye.

Love the style. Only thing is the heal could be firmer as the heal collapses when I try to just step into the shoe.

Returned for a smaller size, have not heard back.

the shoe is fine however the color seem to be a little off black instead of black other than that it is comfortable it fits good I normally wear a 10 and this is a 10 and a half and it fits very well

Quality was good but too wide and big. Returned for another style that fits perfectly

Comfortable, stylish slip os