Customer Reviews Birkenstock Buckley Shearling - Suede

Snug but warm

I am returning becasue I did not know they are Narrow. I need a regular. 6.5

These were too small. But what’s more disappointing than that is that in the right shoe, toward the top above the toes and along the right side of it it is MISSING shearling.

I wear almost only Birkenstocks due to metatarsal pain and needed a black enclosed pair for winter. These are very narrow. Much different fit than a Boston. The elastic piece immediately started hurting the top of my foot. The fur is very cozy but also made the footbed feel odd. They are like having a very expensive pair of slippers on. I’ll stick with Bostons.

Shoe is narrow. My feet do best in a narrower shoe, however these are narrow all the way to the toes. Definitely not a wide toe box here. I usually wear a 39 in Birkenstock sandals, but these seemed short and thought the next size would be good and maybe be less narrow. But no dice. The next size up puts the heel cup and arch support and toe grip bump in the wrong place. I’m sad to send them back because I thought they would work for me. I have been on a long quest to find a pair of slippers that are comfy, warm, arch support, accommodate narrow feet but have a wide toe box. It’s a daunting task. SIGH! Why don’t manufacturers offer narrow for their slippers? Also why would anyone want to cram their toes into a squished space when they want to be cozy?

These are the cutest shoes. I ordered them in the pink and they looked great on my feet. They are so uncomfortable. I wore them all day a couple of days in a row and my feet hurt so bad. The footbed and arch support feel hard. I usually wear Naots but they don't come in narrow so I thought I would try Birikenstock since I had heard many good things about them but these just don't work for me. Maybe another style would work better.

I purchased the same shoe last year in Grey(40N) and loved them so much I decided to order another pair. The shearling in this shoe is much thiner and not as cozy.

Love but had to return. Black shearling rubbed off and turned parts of my feet black. Exchanged for tea color, have pink gets dirty really quick. Very comfortable.

Just so disappointed with so expensive slippers the shearling wore off in just two months that they are unusable in upcoming fall winter

Loved these but returning because the buckle fell off. I will order another. ?

the elastic rubbed my foot and gave me a blister

I have another pair of Birkenstock mules that are lined but they don't rub the top of my foot to the point of bleeding like this pair did. I think the shearling lining is defective on this pair.

I own several pair of Birkenstock sandals and love them all. I love the look of these clogs and their comfort, but the shearling feels cheap. After only a couple of wears, the footbed is worn down and some of the shearling has fallen out. I don’t think they will last past 1 season. For the price I really expected them to last for years. I’ll stick with Uggs next time!

This is my first pair of Birks so I didn’t know what to expect. I am having problems with my feet and if my podiatrist didn’t tell me I needed these shoes I would have sent them back. I have long ,narrow feet and although these shoes are supposed to be narrow the right one is slightly wider. The shearling in that shoe is thinner than in the other shoe and it doesn’t go through the toe box. This is poor quality control. As I said before I needed a shoe I could walk in so I took a chance and kept the shoes. I do think they are good for my feet. I will try the Birks sandals next and hope the fit is better.

I wear a 40 in the Birkinstock sandals, the 40 in this was too short

Very disappointed. The shearling lining is black. I asked specifically if it would be gray and was assured that it was gray. Not so. The shearling lining is black and even just trying on the shoes caused black smudges on my feet. Back they come.

I thought the style of these was pretty cute and I loved the soft pink color, however they were just not comfortable at all. Sad to have to return them.

Love the look but one shoe on the upper inside lip, under the top flap is curled down. That means everytime I try to put this one shoe on, that part is gonna get stuck & I'm going to have to try to put my finger in there to straighten it out. They are $170 shoes so I'm returning them bc of being defective.

I just want people to know that the inside of shoe is NOT gray as pic shoes. Was disappointed when it came and was black..

I wanted so badly to love these. I thought they would be the perfect fall (and some winter) shoes! Unfortunately, they just didn't feel good on my feet. The fur inside went up until the toe but then there was a bare patch without fur that felt very weird and not comfortable.

I really expected some cushioning in this shoe but no, nothing. Hard as a rock, so prepare yourself. The large Birkenstock arch, just too much for me.

I have the lavender, which is perfect, but this black pair is too big. The right shoe wont even stay on my foot. Also, the toe is wonky, like there is a little too much leather gathered onto the vamp. Shame, as I so wanted the black ones. Quality in this pair does not coincide with price! So I am returning them.

This shoe was cute but felt a little tight. You may want to size up

Too narrow I wore them once / I wish I had returned them

Tried wearing in the house a couple of times, and had to almost immediately take them of because the right shoe hurt the outside of my foot. When I finally looked inside to see what was causing the pain, I discovered that the shearling did not cover the entire inside of the right shoe, causing a lump that made the shoe painful. This is poor quality control on the part of Birkenstock.