Customer Reviews Columbia Ice Maiden™ Shorty

Very good shoe overall. Got a size up so I could layer socks. Took to Alaska, and did just fine in daytime about 30 degrees with 2 wool sock layers, outside for about an hour. At night for 20 degrees, also with 2 sock layers, being outside for ~2 hours was OK but started to need toe warmers by the 3rd hour. However, the next day it was around 5 degrees and even with toe warmers in, got very cold after an hour. Still performed pretty good overall, though would like some more cushion on the sole, and more traction on the bottom. Slipped a couple times on icy parts.

Warm with sock layers. Get a size up so you can add sock layers. I am returning this one because it is too small, and am getting the size 8.5 which is perfect for me. It's not super comfortable with just one layer of socks (no padding) so that is another reason why someone would want to get a size up to layer

These are warm and comfortable. They provide adequate support as I suffer from plantar fasciitis and they don't aggravate it at all. I do wish I'd sized up an extra size as thick socks can make them a bit snug.

So comfy and so cute! Sizing is as expected and shoes feel perfect!

They are just as they are pictured, they're true to size, comfy to walk in, have not used them in snow conditions yet, but they're super cute and I can't wait to experience snow for the first time in them.

Great fit and color. They are as warm as you would expect. Great for work or play. The only negative is the sole inside the boot is pretty hard. I will add some inserts to keep them comfortable, but a softer insole would be all it would take to make them perfect.

Love them! Kinda stiff but hopefully they loosen up.

Comfy and works for winter. Not heavy and keep your feet warm.

Thank you fits okay I have a wide foot and wish it were a tad wider but it fits fine.

So far so good but time will tell when the rain & snow hits. I went with the shorter boot because I'm in my 70's & don't need to be lacing up a higher boots & I wear my pants over my boot anyways so you only see the side, front & back of the boot not the top. The only draw back to this boot for me was I wish it had come in the "Wide" width like the regular Ice Maiden higher boot.

Bought this for Alaska trip and it was great. Was very good for a temperature of -11F. The only thing is one of the boots were tight with the winter socks. Would recommend it anyway.

Style and comfort in one footwear. Perfect for winter, I can't wait to use it during the wintee