Customer Reviews Naturalizer Teresa

I saw these shoes at MACY’S and I tried on a11W to big. Therefore, I ordered an 11M the top of the shoe pressed into my feet and my toes felt cramped. Such a sexy shoe but I’m returning them.

Too much toe cleavage

I wear an 11 and fit wise, these are fine. A little gap in the back but I don't think it'll require a heel pad. The black patent is nice and for a heel they are comfortable enough. I only gave it 3 stars because the beige lining comes up too high and is clearly visible with the shoe on. Might be less noticeable against light skin, but against my brown skin it definitely stands out. They either should have made the lining black, or cut it lower. I'm still debating on keeping them, because they do check a lot of boxes, but the lining really bugs me.

This shoe seems nice, but for me was large. I wear a 7W and it felt like 1/2 size too big. I ordered the nude color and it is more of blush.

I have never had the issue with one shoe being snug and the other shoe looser. No I don't have one foot bigger than the other. Customarily my shoes always fit the same on each foot. Now I'm concerned after they stretch the one shoe might be too loose. I can't say this particular pair of shoes is true to size because one shoe is bigger.

Way too narrow for my toes. Very pretty shoes though.

Not comfortable which is surprising considering these are Naturalizers

This shoe was too long for my foot. I could not keep my heel in the shoe while walking. I tend to wear a 9 W but this shoe was too long

It’s a gorgeous shoe and felt like it would have been VERY comfortable had it fit. I was very disappointed!

Love the style, Love the feel of the leather...so soft. But Size 6 is my usual shoe size, mayb a 6.5 for pointed toe pumps, but these were so tight i truly did not think the 6 would feel much different. (& a 7 would most likely be too long) Sad to have to return :((

I had to return these because although the length was fine, the toes were a little more pointed than rounded, and thus gave a bunion on my left foot grief. Pretty comfortable though for higher heels. The narrow still slipped off my heels (believe I am an AA or AAA), and I also have a high arch so there was a lot of "gap" to the inside of the shoes. Beautiful shoes though, and they make your legs look great.

Too tight in toe box.

These heels are the perfect looking work heel with a beautiful platform that makes your legs look great! However, when I first got mine they felt really tight in the toes (I'm between a 9-8.5) and I ordered a 8.5. I decided to keep them in hopes they would stretch out. Within a few hours of wearing them (walking a few blocks for work) I had a massive blister on my heel from the shoe slipping. I have ordered an 8 in hopes that it will fix the slipping issue.

These were really cute and probably would have been comfortable had they fit. I actually double-checked the size since they seemed so big. I'm pretty consistent with sizing so this was a surprise for me.

Depending on the brand, I land between sizes and widths for pumps. The Rockport Total Motion Pump in 8.5W fits better and doesn't have any heel slippage on either foot compared to this shoe. Too bad, the platform is cute.

Of all the shoes I ordered, I was hoping for these to work the most. Such a versatile, timeless look. Unfortunately, my foot sat between 2 sizes and the shoe had no flexibility with your foot.

Beautiful shoe but too small in the toe box. Had to return.

These looked super cheap - the sole is plastic/rubber and they slip off the heel.

I agree with the comment on the big toe knuckle due to how the show is cut. Extremely uncomfortable and I only tried them on in my home for 10 minutes. I will be returning them.