Customer Reviews Florsheim Montinaro Cap Toe Oxford

I liked the color and style of these shoes. The fit was true. I wouldn't recommend them if you're going to be wearing them 2-3 times a week because I don't think they'd hold up but if you're going to wear them 2-3 times a month they might work for you. They're a good value as long as you don't plan on wearing them every other day or so - they don't look like they'd stand up to that. But for the price they're a good value.

Clean look. Great for formal events. Comfortable enough to wear for a long night of dancing!

Nice looking shoe. Fits well. Scuffs somewhat easily, but I condition fairly frequently.

Great pair of shoes: really comfortable, and the color is gorgeous. The fitting was a little wide but overall it's been good.

Great looking shoe and very good quality as usual by Florsheim. I ordered a 13E which is supposed to be wide. There is nothing wide about this shoe. If you have a slim foot this is an awesome shoe. If not, order a size bigger for the width only. Let's see if the shoe opens up with use.

Great shoe for a great price.

I have purchased Florsheim shoes for nearly 40 years. From time to time I have gone out and purchased other brands only to come back to Florsheim for their consistent quality and comfort. I injured my ankles in high school and these are the only shoes that give them the support needed for any length of time. This time however I think someone in quality control missed the mark. The shoes are good but the shoelaces which should have been for dress shoes appear to be for boots. I hope the shoes last as long as my previous purchases, but I had to go out and purchase shoe laces that did not drag the ground behind me.

This shoe is a good deal for the price paid. The sides of the shoe consist of a single, thinner leather layer compared to some more expensive shoes, but results in faster break ins. The outsole isn't leather, but looks better than black rubber and has good grip. The shoe is fashionable and can be wore outside without regard to wear and tear due to the affordable price.

Fine and elegant. Soft enough but would prefer soft sole

Bought them in the saddle brown color, darker than the online image. I was hoping for a lighter color scheme but they look nice and will still match well.

Comfortable shoe! I prefer shoes with a leather sole and this brand doesn't disappoint.

This is a nice shoe. However, the width was an issue. When I purchased the shoes they only had them in the D width. I needed a medium. Besides that this is a great shoe.

Got what I expected and would buy again.

Very nice shoes. Fairly comfortable right out of the box. I did have to return the first pair that were 1/2 size too big. No free shipping on returns was a bit of a bummer, but otherwise very happy with these shoes.

Beautiful shoes and great quality, but they seem to run about half a size larger. I typically fit perfectly in size 7s from Florsheim, but my heels slip in these and stick on heel pads don't help.

It's a beautiful shoe with a traditional elegance. Unfortunately, it fits oddly, especially at a small size. It doesn't match the fit of other similarly sized shoes from Florsheim. I had a 1/2 size smaller, but this feels 1-1/2 sizes larger. Still a quality shoe

Good for the price, but nothing spectacular. Also fairly comfortable, would recommend.

Seems to have the size run much larger than I would expect.

Great looks. Fit was not as good as cardinelli--less flexibility around the toes. Workmanship was excellent and shipping prompt.

I was disappointed with this shoe. I have a pair of the same shoes in burgundy that I bought at men's wearhouse that have rubber soles and that comfortable and sturdy and show no wear after 2 1/2 years. These have leather soles and are lighter and feel like they are made with lower quality materials and do not look or feel as nice.

As a dress shoe goes, it looks and dresses well. Unfortunately the last was slightly cramped despite buying a 3E. Should work well for evening wear

I like the styling and durability of Florsheim shoes, but the XXW in this shoe was too narrow. I returned the shoes because they were much too narrow and tight. Also there are inches of wasted space in the design of the long narrow toe.

Bought these in my size. Very tight. Maybe 1/2 size up would have been better. The "Montinaro " is a really nice shoe but bought the " Mid Town " in my size and what a difference. Love the Mid Towns.

These are really nice shoes. The reason that I rated them a 3 is that I ordered them because they came in Wide, which our youngest son needed. Turns out, they're no wider than normal. I double checked the shoes and the box, and they were supposed to be wide. They fit our other son, who doesn't require a wide, so we kept them since they were a nice quality.

I really liked the shoes, but it was not what I expected. This has the size as if it had been changed and I feel a little bigger than it should be, the box came broken. I hope this comment is a reference for future purchases. Thank you,