Customer Reviews Smartwool Secret Sleuth

If these fit, I would give them 5 stars. I wear a size 11M shoe, and purchased these in size Large (10.5 - 12.5). Even though they should fit a foot much bigger than mine, I had to stretch them to get them on, which means as soon as my foot flexed, the back of the sock popped off. After 5 steps, I had a wad of fabric at the ball of foot. I have the Hide and Seek socks in size L, and they fit perfectly... unfortunately, they are too high in front to wear with ballet flats. I purchased the men's No Show socks, which are actually shorter in the front than the women's Hide and Seek, but again, still to high for ballet flats. My search continues. I LOVE Smartwool and it's really the only sock I buy anymore. My husband turned me onto them... we were traveling and I forgot socks, so he let me use his SW thin business socks. My go to socks are the Best Friend and Cable. So sad that this particular design didn't work for me.

most of the socks was fine--the polyester shiny hem, not so great. I returned them--I don't know why smartwool has started to add synthetics into their products.