Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Jaclyn

I ordered the Sam Edelman Jaclyn boots and also a pair of the Blundstone BL558 boots. I was looking for a classier type winter boot than my Sorels or Merrells. I also needed the tread. We live in New Hampshire and are constantly on snow/ice. I kept the Sam Edelman Jaclyn boots. I've worn them twice now during/after snowstorms and they have worked great. They are a little tough to get on at first, but fit was great once my foot was in. They're also a little hard to get off, but hopefully that will all loosen up as I wear them. I wear a size 10 and have a medium to narrow foot. I always order medium footwear.

These booties are great looking but somewhat stiff and narrow at the toes. They are not comfortable enough for me so I am returning. They are also slightly too long and I am typically a size 8.

The fit was true to size. I have slightly wider feet due to bunions so I always have to go half size up. Recommend others do the same if you have wide feet. The construction of the boot is quality. The leather feels supple and shoe is sturdy. Outsole is a grippy rubber — good for snow, ice, rain. Keep in the mind the heel part is made of some kind of nylon material, not leather. Not a disappointment; but not clear in the description. If you want all leather, this boot is not for you. Love the embossed trim on the back of the heel. Adds a special touch to an otherwise classic boot silhouette. Great shoe!!

I was looking for a Chelsea boot style and that was my main reason for choosing these boots -- my usual go-to brand for boots is Born and their Chelsea was sold out in my size. I didn't think it would be much of an issue since this is an all leather boot but it was honestly too hard and stiff I could barely put them on. The strap/loop is also too small to be helpful with this issue. Once on, I did not think they would get much more comfortable - they were that unfortunate combo of being a little too big/long but at the same time too narrow/tight. They really hurt for the 10 minutes or so I had them on and my partner had to help me take them off. Style-wise, the brown stripe detail on the back would look better if it were matte -- a small detail but I thought that the shiny patent leather and the SE logo/brand made the whole boot look cheap and corny. The chunky lug sole was really good looking, however, and I might try the new Blundstone's if I look for a rugged boot again. Otherwise I will wait until Born brings back more Chelseas!

It was very stylish but a little too pointy for a rugged shoe. The 11 was too big but the 10 too small. I had to return both. Zappos is so great to accommodate my size problems??

I bought these to replace a 4-yr old pair of Timberland Chelsea boots. Those boots have served me well over the years. i wasn't sure about this style bc of the lug sole (i don't want a heavy shoe) but let me tell you the lug sole adds cushion and style to the shoe. also, i hadn't fully accounted for the slim and slightly almond shaped toe but it is GREAT. the Chelsea boot straddles utilitarian and fashion styles and this one strikes the balance for me. The shoes are not heavy and the top edge where they hit my leg is not rough. I will also add that they are treated for rain/ snow so these are easily a 3 season shoe. i will add that i kept the shoes around the house for a few days in order to try with different styles of sock at the end of the day and on the first day i was skeptical (toe box felt tight) but i hit on the perfect combo of boot & sock (thin wool trouser sock or wool footie w/ them) and have worn them 3 days all day this week already. i typically wear a 10 in boots (10.5 in athletics, 9.5/10 in other footwear) and i got the 10 and kept it. SO GLAD I bought from Zappos!

I absolutely adore these boots. They are so warm and comfy...even after walking all over Boston in the snow. A great purchase!

These boots have really nice styling, with the added bonus of being waterproof. Comfortable from day one, although a little stiff just because of the waterproof leather (totally worth it!). I love the little brown detail up the back and wear them all the time!

Bought these boots and wore them all weekend. They are warm but not to bulky. They were comfortable from the first time I put them on. The fit was perfect.

Nothing is cute or dainty in a size 11, but these resembled my husband's size 15s, and the chunky heel didn't help. The fit was good, but a little wide in the heel - my foot lifted up every time I took a step. Good materials, though - I really did consider keeping them for a minute, but in the end, they were too clunky. Probably great if you have smaller feet.

This boot is heavy and sturdy. I was looking for something more feminine. The leather is rather stiff, I found a boot with softer leather.

Love the look of these. Saw them in store but they didn't have my size. I knew Zappos would come to the rescue. I normally wear an 11, but they were too big in store and when the 10.5 arrived it fit perfectly. I purchased in black suede which is classy enough to wear to work or with jeans, pants, dresses and leggings, etc. They are super fashionable and very comfortable, and i've worn them for 2 weeks in lots of weather and they are holding up well. Pleased with my purchase! Would definitely buy again.

I bought these to replace an Ecco boot in a similar style. These fit great, but they are really stiff and need a lot of breaking in time before I can take them on vacation. They are truly waterproof! Very sturdy boot.

I would say this almost run a bit big. When you initially put them on they are very tight because they’re narrow, but after wearing them a day they loosen up quite a bit. So I would stick to a snug initial fit! Love them have worn them 4 times in a week!

I am usually a true 7.5 and medium width. I just received the 7.5 in the mail and they are super cute but snug in width. I will return for an 8. Hoping so bad that they will fit as I love the look and the waterproof benefit!

I purchased the black suede last year on sale elsewhere. Really like the black with the tan/brown strip on back....nice contrast. Wanted a brown boot so decided to go with Sam Edelman dark taupe, same boot, Jaclyn. Initially, difficulty pulling on. After break gets easier. I wear a size 9 but generally always purchase a 9 1/2 in a boot. My feet are wide. Jaclyn boot is narrow in width but has room in toe bed and seem long. So not the perfect fit. I wear a thinner sock with these boots. For some reason my black pair wears better than the dark taupe. The fit in the black is better. The Taupe stretched out way more first wear in terms of length. Good looking boot and overall comfort even though my feet are wide. Great look with jeans and leggings. May have to wear a little thicker sock since the boot stretched out so much but catch 22 because of the narrow width, wide foot.

Beautiful boots, but they were loooong and more narrow than other mediums. Also, no insole to speak of and what's there is not removable. They went back.

Really hard to get on! I ordered these a half size larger than my usual size so I could wear them with thick socks. Despite this, they were so difficult to pull on, even with a shoe horn. The elastic is not quite stretchy enough and the boot is rather stiff, so they definitely could have done with a zipper. However, the style is great, they seem well-made, and fairly comfortable once on, so I’ll be keeping them and hoping they loosen up a bit!

Love my new booties!!!

They are comfortable and look good!

Love these boot so much! they were comfortable from the first minute. I look forward to wearing them!