Customer Reviews TOMS Sicily

Love them!

These felt comfortable but just weren't very flattering. My husband said they look like "old lady shoes," and he's right, although I can't put my finger on what exactly makes them look so frumpy.

These fit great, but they are a metallic finish which you cant see in the photos.

Very cute but offered minimal support

I was disappointed in the fit of these sandals. Although I like flat sandals, I was hoping for a slightly more cushioned insole. I was also a little disappointed in the style and thought they looked cuter in the picture than in person.Additionally, the straps over the forefoot were just a little bit narrow and might irritate my moderate bunion. Those straps were not adjustable and didn't fit quite right.

I really wanted these to work because I liked they way they looked and I'd love to support an ethical company. They just felt too narrow in my regular size. Half a size up and they were still narrow and too long. Tom's classic canvas shoes fit me similarly, so I would guess if Tom's other shoes fit you, these ones will too. Nice soft leather, great color.

The soles felt very flat like fancy cardboard. They smacked a lot as I tried to walk and they just looked bulky and slightly too big on my feet. Changing sizes would not have changed much so I returned. They were fine sandals just not what I was looking for.

I liked the look of this shoe until I put in on my foot. It felt heavy and floppy. Not good for walking any distance.

Not a Toms fan I think highly of the Toms mission, but as much as I try, I cannot wear their shoes, and my latest attempt was the final straw -- no arch support, insole way too long, the shoes looked cheap. Very disappointed.

This is a cute sandall but there is absolutely no arch support and my feet needs cushioning. I returned them with no problem and ordered a sandal that is more comfortable.

Not good for me. Straps felt stiff, too large, too hard, irritated. Returned them.

I really wanted to like these but my feet squeak in them and sounds like I’m farting when I’m walking ..... no thanks . Please start using real leather . I’m so sick of every pair of sandals making farting noises when I walk

Cute but after a few months of wearing these a couple of times a week, a strap broke. I’m disappointed. I bought toms because I thought they would last.

Cute sandals. Horribly uncomfortable. Tom's has never done me wrong which is why I decided to go ahead with purchasing sandals and that was a mistake. Extremely disappointed. Don't wear these unless you're going to sit all day.

I love Toms, but these were huge. They had to go back