Customer Reviews TOMS Sicily

Occasionally snug as i pull the on but with a little adjustment they're great

Love these. They are buttery soft and nearly pillow-like.

I LOVE these sandals. They are super cute and comfortable.

I read reviews and ordered a half size down, and they fit perfectly. Super comfy right out of the box, love these sandals!

These are super comfy. They run about a half size large. I was hoping the brown was more neural But it’s more of a caramel brown.

I loved these sandals the moment I saw them. As soon as I put them on they were just perfect on my foot. My feet can be a bit wide in sandals especially ones with straps but these gave me no trouble at all. They stayed on my foot with no sliding or rubbing in any awkward places no breaking in needed.

I really like these. As a person with a size 12 foot, I don’t find many cute shoes but I thought these were cute and now I have a summer sandal!

Great fit, easy to dress up or down

Comfortable, casual sandal. Cute with casual dresses. Fits well and so far no issues with rubbing/blisters, almost no break-in period.

Looking for a pair of summer sandals and these were great. I have super narrow feet and these do run a bit wide, but not wide enough that they're going to be a problem. I'm usually somewhere around an 8 or 8.5 and I ended up sizing down to the 8. My foot wiggled a bit less. But super comfy and cute without being too gladiatory!

Really cute and comfortable shoes. Fit perfectly.

comfy, like to wear them with flared jeans ?

Perfect casual sandal. Maybe a little lighter in color than I had expected, but perfect anyways!

I had ordered these in an 8, and though I liked how they felt, I felt they were a bit too big. So I ordered the 7.5, and they fit and look so much better!! I love the style, it reminds me of the platforms I used to wear back in the 70s! The straps feel a tiny bit snug, but I'm sure the leather will stretch a bit. Now I need a good pedicure to really show them off....does Zappos offer pedis? (Just kidding!)

I love these sandals! They practically mold to your feet and are super comfortable!

These are exactly what I was looking for! They're great for going from work to out with coworkers/friends. Arch support and overall fit are the same as the traditional TOMS shoes I own.

The fit is good and the material is really pretty. This shoe is versatile and matches anything.

Shoes were cute buy I ultimately returned them. My feet looks like sausages stuffed in casing. I am a size 12 so there was no sizing up for me. Regular Toms fit me though.

Really like these. About a half size larger than anticipated but quite comfortable. Will reorder in smaller size.

Normally I'm a size 6W in sandals, but the 6 was actually wide enough for me. The black leather is a nice style and I like the low arch sole. Unfortunately the sole length was slightly too long. The biggest issue, though, was that the upper part where the straps cross pinched as I walked so they had to go back.

Cute sandals. Love the style. Size was good but no arch support. I do not recommend long distance walking in these sandals.

I usually wear a size 10 in Toms, so I ordered these sandals in a 10. When I first got them, they were the tiniest bit loose and that was on the last available hole on the ankle strap. But I have pretty long, skinny, narrow feet so I accepted this at the time. It only took a few days of wearing them out and about for me to realize my mistake. The ankle strap stretched out even more and my foot flopped about in the sandal. I wish I could have returned them for a smaller size but I had already taken off the tags. I bought another pair in size 9.5, which are a much better fit. My feet feel very secure and snug and not I'm even on the last ankle strap hole yet! Overall, pretty classy and classic sandals for a fair price. Just go half a size down if you have skinny feet like me!

These fit true to size. They are very comfortable, right out of the box! The leather is very soft. They don’t have much support- I wouldn't wear them if I was to be on my feet all day. If you want an around the town go-to sandal, this is it!

Cute and comfortable, but they were a little too wide for my slim foot.