Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Hai

These are SO cute!! The tan suede is beautiful. The 3” heel is a flattering and comfortable height. I’m normally an 8.5/8.5w in San Edelman flats, so ordered these in a 9 to allow enough room for socks/inserts. The foot fit really well, but, sadly, the calf is way too narrow for my athletic/wide calves and I have to return them. Instead, I bought the Sam Edelman Hilty ankle booties in 9w (similar style, but below the calf) and those fit really well.

These shoes were really narrow and the calf part was huge. Even with jeans and I don't have tiny calves. The style is perfect for what I needed and they are well-made, kind of an imitation of the Stuart weitzman's for a quarter of the price but they just did not work for me unfortunately. My search continues..

These are gorgeous boots! I would have kept them, except the calf is too wide at the top and all the way down. The lack of structure in the upper indicates that these will sag in the ankle over time. If you plan to wear these with jeans--they might be for you.

I wanted to love these, but they were very loose and baggy in the ankle and were not flattering. I got the blue snakeskin and the color is brighter than the picture, but still really pretty and fun. But the boots were saggy and not cute; I returned them.

Calf and ankle were too big.

Too wide through shaft, so disappointing. In size 10.5 (I ordered 1/2 size up as suggested which fit my foot great) the circumference is almost 16" at the widest point, 15" at top... I am not small at 160lb and have very thick and muscular calves yet I still swim in these. Looks sloppy. Also they are uncomfortably high even on my 5'9 1/4" legs- top hits the bone of my tibial plateau and is even more uncomfortable digging into back of knee if I sit. Would be more flattering 4" shorter. The suede color and quality is excellent and as described. Soft to touch. ZAPPOS - Please give more accurate measurements - I will be returning two other pairs of boots for exactly the same reason!

I loved the look but the shoes were too tight in the toe and too loose around the ankles, causing them to bunch up. Had to return.

The size and style are great. These shoes are not comfortable from the moment you put them on.

I thought these would be wide calf since this style popped up in my search. I couldn’t get them over my calves. Note the calf measurement and plan accordingly. The description indicates some flexibility for the calf area, but sadly they were still too tight on me. They're lovely shoes, just too tight in the calf area.

Definitely small for the size. I ordered a half size up and they were way too tight on my feet/toes. They seem like nice boots...just way too small.

These would have been great but I received a pair that looked like 2 different boots and had a lot of wear marks in the suede on both. These were not wrapped well nor in the original box, not sure why but this is not typical for Sam Edelman, this may be why they looked horrible.

These are not real suede! The price was ridiculous for cheap boots. I’m very disappointed.

I received the boots not in their original box. They were folded over and stuffed in a small box. Very disappointed.