Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Hai

these are my favorite boots but they run small. I am so sad I have to return them

This is a beautiful boot. However, I bought this boot for my daughter who wears a size 10 and also has athletic calves (volleyball player) and the boots did not fit her in the calve area. The did not even go up! But that is not the boots fault! I would still recommend this boot as it is sleek and classy!

I love love these boots style fit of “foot” but the boot shaft ..... I almost had to return them. I ordered them specifically because reviews said the shaft was Excessively wide, this is definitely not the case. I do have a wider calf but I fit into most boots, usually issues with Vince Camuto and Tory Burch. Possibly manufacturer made an adjustment because of prior reviews, many people returned them because they were too wide. Just be aware that this is not a roomie boot shaft when purchasing. They are very tight (compression socks) on me but the style, at least for me, is worth the hope of a slight stretch.

Nice boot using quality materials. However, The shaft was too wide, and the color has a lot of yellow tones. Return

I had to exchange for one size up. They felt a bit small across the top of the foot. The styling is awesome!

Really love thee boots but ended up being too soft and slouchy. I was looking for a boot that was stiffer and would not slouch over time.

I wear a 9 and purchased a 9. It was a least a half a size too small. My friend loved them and they fit her. She's 8.5. Instead of sending them back she's now the new owner of these boots. The styling and quality were good. Just not comfortable due to size. Also could use a little padding.

Actually, these boots were awesome! They fit well and were of decent quality. I felt the heel was just too chunky to be faced with a tan sole. If they had black soles, I would have kept them.

These are really nice looking boots and I wanted to keep them, but the toe box is too small for me. I wear orthotics and I wouldn't be able to use them with these boots due to the small toe box. Even so, the boots are stylish and pretty much exactly what I was looking for other than the fit.

Overall a good fit. Got half size larger and it was a good choice. Calf a little wide, but wear leg warmers, which take up some slack. Have suede boots, but liked the fact that these were at least 2" higher.

beautiful boots - but, too small. sadly, had to return. Zappos was their usual convenient best!

Great boots, beautuful color and quality leather. Fits well in the calf and I often have issues with most boots being too wide in that area. The only problem is that it is quite narrow in the foot and arch. I have average to narrow feet and I wear 7.5 or 8. I went with the 8, but it is still too narrow to be comfortable. I contemplated to order 8.5, but not sure if that would be too large. So I've decided to return.

Cute boot but very difficult to get on - a no go for anyone with athletic calves. The zipper is located only at the ankle and no real place to grab to pull the shaft over the calf. If knee high boots are normally snug around your calves, this likely won't work for you.

I wanted to love these but other reviewers were right that the calf was too tight! I loved the style of these boots and they look and feel better in person. The heel was a good medium height, the shaft came up right to my knee (I’m 5’8”), and the pointy toe didn’t make the toe box too narrow. The only flaw was how small the calf was. I have fairly average calves, not overly muscular or large, and I couldn’t pull these up all the way let alone dream of tucking jeans in. If you have smaller calves these are a great option but unfortunately I couldn’t make them work!

Beautiful boot! Unfortunately too small and narrow. I am returning the boots. If you order, size up.

Wish I listened to the reviews. I’ve seen a few bloggers post these and they look SO cute. Not shockingly most of them are probably actually smaller in person and the boots look like they fit them fine. I could not fit these over my calves. Mind you I do work out so I have more athletic calves but I’ve never had issues in other boots. I wish they fit because they are so cute but literally cut off my circulation so had to return