Customer Reviews Dr. Scholl's Madison

The black lizard print is plastic-like and awful. They look and feel cheap. Do not recommend that version - but I've had other colors/fabrics of this shoe and loved.

Terrible sizing. At least one size to small. Totally inaccurate. You’ll waste time buying these due to having to return them and wait for your refund

These shoes were sent to me clearly worn already. I’m disappointed because I actually thought they were cute but should not have been sent I’ve used or gently worn pair. They have scuffs and dirt on the sides and bottom of them

The shiny plastic piece on the back cuts into your heal. Have to return.

They arrived with no insole.

I did love these shoes for a few days, but then I had a horrible case of athletes foot, and I have never had a problem before. I stopped wearing the shoes and it went away. The same thing happened to my 11 year old daughter. I wish I could rerun both pairs as it was over $100 I shoes that I just have to toss out.

I was looking for a good pair of shoes to travel through Europe with. Unfortunately, these were not the best. I was not impressed with the material - they looked 'cheap'. I bought them in the Black Lizard print. The photo looks better than the real thing. The footbed was comfortable, but the shoe bulged out by the ankle as I walked. This made my foot look big and fat. I also bought a pair of Taos 'Star' for the trip and they were perfect! (More expensive, but perfect) The 'Star" was so comfortable, had a great footbed and super arch support. I had high hopes for the Dr. Scholl's 'Madison', but ended up disappointed. I learned my lesson - don't go cheap, you get what you pay for. And when you are doing a lot of walking, you need great shoes!

Very narrow through the toes and run a full size too small. Was a glue spot on the right shoe on top. Disappointed, really liked the look of this shoe.

I'm on my second pair already due to the first not holding up. My second ones have been worn three times and they are already starting to fall apart by the toe on the sole. They are very comfortable and cute, but due to lack of quality, I will not be getting a third pair.

So first impression I loved these shoes. LOVED them. They were comfortable and I wore them all day up and down on my feet and thought they were going to be great. The next morning, I was in so much pain. Something in these shoes hurt my legs so bad that I couldn't walk correctly and had knee, shin, and ankle pain all day. Thank god for Dansko clogs coming to the rescue so I could go to work. Sadly threw the box away so I'm unable to return them. Sucks they caused me so much pain because they were really cute.

The show is very comfortable, fits true to size, and looks pretty similar in style as the pictures show, but the quality is absolutely terrible. I wore the shoes once, and very lightly - no heavy activity or anything, and the shoes are already so scuffed up and look in awful shape. If you're looking for a shoe that you don't care about and are going to look much worse for the wear very quickly these are fine, but if you're hoping they'll maintain a clean look for more than a few wears, definitely not worth the money.

These are very stiff; doesn't seem to bend with your foot.

The material is so stiff, very uncomfortable for me. They’re also a bit wide. And the material is so thick and bulky it not flattering. Made my feet look clunky. Tried them at the same time as several other similar styles and these were the least attractive of the bunch. The footbed felt ok, but not super supportive and not enough arch for me.