Customer Reviews Dr. Scholl's Madison

I bought 2 pairs last year and loved them. Was able to wear them right off the bat without socks. They didn't need to be broken in at all. This year I decided to buy a few more and was sorely disappointed. They added some sort of liner inside and it rubs on both my heels and I ended up with a blister on one of my toes after just wearing for one day. Tried with socks and they were tight. Would NOT recommend! Wished I had bought more last year. I switched to Naturalizer - Marianne this year and they are perfect.

Disappointingly smaller than my size. Didn’t want the hassle of trying different size, diff width, so just returned than.

Nice shoe was disappointed that they are too small and my toe was right up against the top. Tried a half size bigger and they flopped off my foot. Not true to size.

I really wanted to like these. I have vans but I needed something with removable foot beds for orthotics. These were such a weird fit even without removing the footbed. They were short but very sloppy on my foot. There’s no way I could have gone smaller in length though. I returned them.

Had to return these, they were way too narrow. Trust the reviews these are very narrow & my width is typically a B. They were also too small, I ordered my size but they felt 1-2 sizes too short. The cushioning did feel pretty good. I wish they fit bc they seemed like they would be pretty comfortable. I also liked the subtle lizard imprint.

Wanted to love this shoe, it is adorable in person. I could barely get my foot in this shoe, once I finally did, it was so tight across the top of my foot, it was cutting off circulation. I have slightly wide feet (in other words, I usually don't need to order a wide, but every now and then I do). That being said...if you have anything other than narrow feet (or slightly narrow feet), I would not recommend. Too bad they don't make it in a wide.

These were really comfortable right out of the box and I was pleased to have them as my new go to shoe. Unfortunately, after a handful of wears the suede uppers started fraying/disintegrating at the perforations. It looked ratty and worn so quickly that I returned them. As one shoe was significantly worse than the other, it may have been a fluke, but I didn't try again and settled on the other pair of Dr. Scholl's slip ons I had purchased at the same time with non perforated leather uppers.

I wore these for an hour and they felt horrible. The material does not breathe and they are very narrow at the toes, your pinky toe feels like it’s on the ledge. Extremely uncomfortable.

Wanted to love these and thought they'd be super comfortable since they're dr scholl's. They are super cute in person and on but returned them because after trying them on I didn't think they were comfortable.

Not to size - runs small

maybe it was the color but not pretty at all. and it was slightly narrow.

Surprised that these were incredibly uncomfortable. Made my feet ache after wearing around the house. No cushion in the sole at all. Felt like I was walking barefoot. I returned & bought another pair of comfy Skechers.

I was sent the wrong item these were not Dr. Scholls nor were they wide width

I’m a bit disappointed with this shoe. I’ve had these for a couple of months and the back part of the shoe get easily stretched out that it’s starting to hurt my heel. Also there is little to no arch support. Not a great shoe to walk around in. It’s also a bit bulkier that the picture shows.

I love the shoes, they are cute and comfortable but I have only had them a couple months and they are coming apart.