Customer Reviews Dr. Scholl's Madison

I usually wear a 10-wide, but these shoes were too large so I exchanged them for a 9-1/2 wide. The 9-1/2 wide is also too large so I will be returning it. The shoe is wider and longer than any of my other 10-wide shoes. I liked the shoes but they are just not the right fit for me.

I bought these a few months ago and LOVED them. The perfect cross between casual and business-casual. I wore them all the time, but then after maybe 2ish months of frequent wear, they started tearing apart where the foot bends with walking. The sole has been very durable but the fabric upper has not. Super disappointed. I want to buy another pair to replace them but don't want to deal with that durability issue again.

These ran very small. I have other Dr. Schols slip on in smaller sizes. I even went up 1/2 a size and they are still tight. I usually wear a 6, I bought a 6.5. Funny thing is I got a 6.5 in their wedge style and those fit just fine. It's tough shopping online even when you have similar styles by same company. They don't all fit the same, strange.

There is not enough heel support, in fact in the heel area the insert actually is slightly lower, which is very uncomfortable. I recommend investing in some heel supports. I've never needed that with a Dr. Scholl's slip on, which is why I like them, so that was very disappointing. There is also a shiny vinyl section on the heel of the shoe that rubs against my foot & is very uncomfortable. I typically love Dr. Scholl's & never have a problem, I wear them for years until I wear them out but this pair has features that aren't typical & are not comfortable. I wish I'd worn them indoors a bit before going out in them-I would have returned.

I like the style and really wanted to like these shoes, but they have done nothing but fall apart since the moment I started wearing them. They are pulling between the rubber and the fabric at the toe, and now the back of the heel is breaking off. I would hope for better quality from Dr. Scholl's.

This shoe is really cute but is cut rather narrow across the top of the foot. I own several Madison shoes by Dr. Scholl's that fit perfectly so ordered the same size. I am disappointed how tight these fit and hope they will stretch and be more comfortable.

Hate these shoes could only wear them once. They were comfy at the store but after wearing them thru the day they are my ankles up

These shoes are so cute but kill my feet. Hurt so bad it gives me Charlie horses in my calves after wearing. Wish I could send them back but I've worn them 3 times already. Really disappointed that I can not wear them.