Customer Reviews Dr. Scholl's Madison

Love the shoe but suggest not getting the "black python." After about a month, the material at the tip of my shoe started to fall off, which created unusual marks throughout the shoe over time. I colored it in with black marker for a while, but the spots from lost material kept coming back. I'll definitely get another pair but not the "black python" material.

To start: I ordered 1/2 size down than my normal size after being told that they stretch, it was a smart move. I absolutely love these shoes. They’re super comfortable and still cute enough that I wear them at work. Unfortunately, I ordered 2 pairs and within less than a month, both pairs started to separate between the rubber bottoms and leather top near the toe box (see picture). My black pair is worse than the picture I have of the tan, but they’re boxed up to be returned already. Zappos has been wonderful in assisting with returns/exchanges. I’m trying the black pair 1 more time before I decide to give these another chance.. I’ve owned so many slip ones after working for major shoe companies in the past and this has never happened, especially near the toe box after 2.5 weeks of inconsistent wearing. I’m hoping these were just defective pairs. Very unfortunate, but a great shoe otherwise.

I ordered this shoe at the end of May because my old pair was wearing out after 2+ years. I placed the order after vacationing in Washington DC where we did a LOT of walking. They are VERY comfortable and cute. The new pair is showing significant wear after 2 months. See the photos. I didn't keep the box because I didn't think there was any possibility I would be returning them. I'm very disappointed.

These shoes are comfortable, but they are a little too wide. When I walk, they don't stay tight against my foot like a glove. They bent when I walked and there was room around my mid foot.

I loved the look of these. They did not give blisters or any irritation. However they have zero arch support! I will not buy these again. For the brand and price I expected supported arch comfort these fail at that.

My second pair because I love them so much! I am on my feet most of the day and it’s super easy with Dr Scholls!

Love these shoes. These are my 5th pair. They start out a snug fit but stretch out as you wear them. The soles aren’t very sturdy - wear out after year of every day wear.

I tiny bit long but wide enough for my feet, even in the Medium width

I started searching for a pair of comfortable and stylish shoes for a trip to NYC and these popped up. When I received the shoes, I thought how are these going to hold up? Well there must be magic clouds in there somewhere because I walked over 20 miles in NYC and my feet didn’t hurt one bit!! If you want supportive and stylish shoes these are it!! I will be buying more!

Usually wear a 9.5 wide; went with the 9 wide that was recommended. I’m a pharmacy tech & these shoes made it through my shift. Super cute. Would buy again.

I wanted a pair of slip on summer shoes and I loved the seafoam color so I took a chance. I was a little worried about the edge on the inside cutting into my right foot but with a little breaking in it doesn't seem to be an issue. I’ve only worn them around the house so I’m not sure about longer walks but I have hope they will be fine. They feel good as to cushioning and I like the style. Plenty of room in the toes and they seem to breathe well too. Overall a good buy.

Really like them, but they gave me blisters on my heels. Kinda bummed cause otherwise they’re comfy & cute.

I just received my second pair in black. Love them! Don't ever want to be without this shoe!

I am a teacher and needed a pair of shoes I could wear all day, which were comfortable. These are perfect! The shoes give good arch support and am able to wear them all day without foot or arch pain.

These are super cute and comfy if you have narrow feet, which I do. I am usually between and 9.5 and 10. I originally ordered the 10, but they were too big so I exchanged them for the 9.5. The 9.5 were almost too small at first, but after wearing them once, they are perfect. Overall, I love them.

Super stylish and comfy!!! Love them!!! Dress up or down with jeans.

These shoes fit nicely, and accommodated my bent/hammer toes and my high arch, well. Style as I expected. There were small spots, one on each shoe, but I expect to get these shoes dirty while walking, so they won't be noticed at all.

Soft, flexible slip-ons. Very comfortable but not much arch support.

I liked these shoes but was not assured by Zappos or Dr. Scholl's (Zappos rep suggested I contact Dr. Scholl's which I did) that they could handle wet cobblestone streets as I wanted them for an upcoming trip. There is a different surface on the sole at part of the heel and the ball of the foot that supposedly would make it more slip resistant, but not enough so to make me comfortable so, with disappointment, I am returning them.

I purchased 2 Dr. School's styles and this one was slimmer and less comfortable than the Original. The shoe itself is really nice but just didn't fit my foot.

Very cute shoes. Received these in 7W. They looked good and felt good except for the heel which was too lose and a little stiff. These shoes would rub a blister. The Hydrangea color is really cute too. I wish they worked for me.

A little narrow in the toes, stuffed some socks in and the top and it stretched nicely. Otherwise very comfortable

I originally ordered a wide and had to return as it was way too wide, returned for the medium width and it fit perfect. I would not recommend wide unless you are super wide in the width of your foot.

The recommended size from zappos was a half size bigger than I normally do. I should have ordered at least my normal size. They were OK in comfort but not awesome. They rubbed on the back of my heals even with socks. Maybe it was because they were too big. I will be returning.