Customer Reviews Dr. Scholl's Madison

Comfortable shoe and good price. Fit true to size. I did return these though because I thought the black lizard material looked a bit cheap and plastic looking. Otherwise good shoe and I would recommend if you are looking at another color.

Can we talk about these cute slip-ons? I'm a teacher and I am on my feet ALL DAY. These Dr. Scholl's can keep up...and keep me up throughout the day! The black leather is universal for my entire wardrobe. Thanks Dr. Scholl's!

I bought these specifically because I wanted a slip-on sneaker that had removable insoles, because I wear custom orthotics. I was super excited to find a pair that allowed me to put in my own insoles. They are cute and comfortable. The only reason I took off one star is because they seem the tiniest bit narrow--not too bad, but enough that when I take a step, the material seems to gap around the sides a little, because the sole is not quite wide enough to cover my entire foot, I guess. It's hard to explain, but anyway, it's not enough to be noticeable to anyone but me, so I still wore them and liked them a lot.

I would have liked to keep these shoes...they seemed comfortable when trying them on around the house. Unfortunately, I didn't pay close attention to the fact that the insoles are memory foam which after a few wearing doesn't offer near the support I need. So, I'll keep looking for a pair of slip-on tennis that have a better insole.

Well, the jury's still out on these shoes. I usually wear an 8.5 or a 9 and bought theses in a 9. They're a bit big, but because of how high they come up on the top of my foot they don't slip or flop around. So, they get a check mark there. However, they also LOOK big and a bit clunky. They're not big enough that I think I could size down, though. Hmmm, subtract a check. I think that being microfiber they're going to be hot...they just don't seem to breathe. I'd like to wear them without socks, but don't want sweaty feet. They don't seem to have much arch support, either. So, I'm leaning toward sending them back and going with leather.

Was looking for a basic, comfortable slip-on and got it. It doesn't bother my ankle or heel much with the padding it has, and the toes are roomy without feeling cavernous. Very easily broken in, the materials aren't very stiff but still keep their form.

I wear a size 7 and when I got them they were extremely hard to get on as if they were a size 5 or 6. I would reccomend going up a half or full size

i love them, I walked around all day(at an outlet mall) and they didn't bother me at all. great. I have a bit of a wide foot and they were fine no problem with it.

I have this same shoe in Black and this Pewter color is at least a half size smaller. Very odd but just letting everyone know it's a great shoe but order a bit larger.

I'm normally a 7 or 7.5 and I ordered both. Unfortunately neither of these fit my foot. The seven's were too small and rubbed my toes and the 7.5 were too big and sloppy. Cute style though and more padding than Vans.

Comfortable and attractive shoe. I typically wear a size 7 and this fit tts. As other reviewers stated, the bone color is really tan and not grey at all. I wanted to check fit with this style, also hoping that a tan neutral would be useful. Although it's nice, I guess I really want a grey color and so this one is not for me.

I usually wear a size 6 but that felt a little tight for these so I ended up with a 6.5 and it's perfect. The breaking in process has been pretty seamless, a little rubbing of the pinky toes but otherwise not bad. I live in NYC and walk a lot, these are great mix of comfort and cute.

Looks great. Fun choice. Great price.

I really liked the style of the shoe but I have wide feet. So I bought a shoe extender that also widens width. I set it up for about one month to stretch. This allowed me to wear the shoe with comfort. It’s not the best walking shoe, but I wear it at work, so it works for that.

These shoes are super comfortable and go with everything. My only complaint is that I work with toddlers and am crawling around on carpet all day; I got the taupe reptile style and the texture on the toes and tops of the shoes have significantly rubbed off. I'll just have to get the suede next time. Other than that, these shoes are great for work and walking.

Comfortable, but fit is really wide.

These shoes are very stylish. I purchased the grey pearlized and in my opinion, it's the perfect metallic look without being too shiny. They fit true to size with plenty of room at the toe so my toes aren't smashed together, but they are a little more stiff than other brands I own. I've only worn them a couple of times, so I don't know if they will loosen up, but even if they don't, they're not uncomfortable or hurt.

I liked the style of this shoe, but it was too narrow across the toe area (size 8), especially for my bunion. therefore had to return.

I love this shoe. This is my 2nd pair. I got the Pewter Snake metallic this time. It looks great in the photo but beware, it is much shinier in person. I kept them but probably wouldn't have purchased if I had seen them first.