Customer Reviews Earth Blythe

These shoes with embossed leather are beautiful. Unfortunately, The bunion on my right foot will not be accommodated even by the wide with because the seams on the side hit it at the wrong angle. A pity!

I ordered the black and brown. They didn't look right in black, but brown was nice. They look great with jeans and pants, but I wanted something I could wear with a skirt and tights too. They made my feet look huge with tights. Maybe i should have ordered a half size down. This size is good in boots, but with thin tights, and no tie, they slip off of my heel when i walk. Even with fairly thick socks the heel slips off. Otherwise, they are very nice.

My arch is high so it was a bit difficult getting into the shoes.

They feel true to size and comfortable however, I haven't really been able to wear due to breaking pinkie toe before they arrived. I will update when I can really test them out therefore I can only give 4 stars.

I'm a 9 in some shoes, 9.5 in others. Tried both, maybe my arch is too high, but the shoe is way too snug around the instep. I could tell they would be so uncomfortable after a few hours. Disappointed, they are very cute.

Very tight across my instep. Returning

I like the lacy etched detail at the sides and back. Super cute shoe, very comfortable. Sadly, they didn't look good on my feet. The toe box is very large. I have long skinny feet, and if I wear something too clunky, my feet look clownish. So I had to return them.

Cute shoe, I love the lacy etched detail at the sides and heel. However, they are too wide for my feet. The rounded toe is a little large and clunky on me. I have long skinny feet, and if I wear something too clunky I look like I have clown feet. I really love how sturdy they are for the 10-month rainy season we have here in the Pacific NW. But they aren't right for me. I'm going to return them and keep looking.

Nice shoe. Snug in toe with socks

I was really excited about these shoes but sadly am returning them. They run very small - hard to cram my foot into my usual size. Also, they don't look as cute in person as they do in the photo. Rather clunky and old-lady like.

I have a size 12 in another pair of Earth shoes and had high hopes for these, but unfortunately they were just way too tight on my foot. My foot is narrow and bony and these felt as if they were just squeezing my foot, they also felt too short. In the end I had to send them back.

I am an older woman who loves shoes, but now has problem feet. This is a darling shoe with smart tooling around the back and sides. Although I could fit my orthotics inside the shoe, the toe bed was too narrow to accomodate a bunion. Oh how I wish!!

I ordered in a 6.5 Wide and this shoe was just too narrow for my foot. The show is very attractive and I wish it would have fit better.

It is nicer in the picture than the actual shoe. It had a cowboy feel about it. Also too big.

I was walking out the back of the shoe, so I ordered an 8.5. I walked out of this one, even though it was smaller in length than the 9. The wide width continues to the heel part. These did not fit the shape of my foot so unfortunately am returning them. They are cute - sorry I had to return them

Attractive shoe, however it was a bit tight. I rarely wear a wide width but I would recommend ordering them in a wide width. They hurt my feet all around. I don't care for the color of the heel or the edge of the shoe. It IS stylish though. I am returning them as I am not crazy enough about them for the price.

I tried these in my usual size, 8.5 wide but there were so large my foot kept slipping out. Tried 8 wide and it was little tight in toe box. Would've considered keeping them anyway but did not like look that much either. I love oxfords but these style does not tolerate round toe, they looked very clunky.

Cute style and nice fit. The “stacked” heel is molded on. The leather quality is very poor - it feels a bit like cardboard, and started losing its dye right away, giving the shoe a mottled appearance. I polished with brown shoe polish, which helped, but the poorly prepared leather sucked up lots of polish.

Oh how I wanted these shoes to be the best. Loved the style, with the stitching, like a cowboy boot. But, my foot is wide with a high instep and I could barely get my foot down into the shoe. When I did, the elastic part on top was just too tight. So, back they go, thanks to Zappo's for their generous policy.

This shoe looks and feels like it is made out of cheap stiff plastic. Super ugly. Returned.

Love the fit and the style. Great arch support. Too bad the workmanship is terrible. The color started to rub off on the first day. Now they look terrible. It seems like they just sprayed the cor on the shoe.

Even with a wide width I was not able to get the shoe on. Can't speak to the arch support because I couldn't get my foot that far in. Cute shoe and just what I'm looking for, a stacked look heel rather than the molded wedge so often used.

Interesting casual alternative to booties and shooties, but leather is very stiff and shoe fits very snugly. I think it would take a long time to break these in. Not at all a good fit for feet with bunions. I will return these.

Tried the 8 D and they were too big (length) so I returned them for a 7 1/2 D and they were way too small. Very disappointed because they style, construction, and arch support were just what I was looking for.