Customer Reviews Earth Blythe

I loved these shoes. At this point in my life I am having a difficult time finding shoes that fit with my orthotic which is huge. I ordered a size larger than my usual size as well as one a size wider. Both were too large. Going back for my normal size to try. The shoes are beautiful. I only wish the heel were as black as the leather shoe.

Everything I was looking for!! Style, Comfort, Quiet (soft soles). I went with wide because some leather shoes can be tight, great choice. Love the textured leather! The insoles are SO comfortable. I am extremely happy !

Beautiful, comfy soft leather shoes. I purchased a 9.5 medium. Unfortunately, the left shoe was a little tighter than the right. I usually have the opposite problem because of a bunion on my right foot.

These shoes are very comfortable and attractive. I can wear them all day. Look great with jeans and slacks.

I am an 8.5 in most shoes (Born, Steve Madden). I got the 8.5 Medium width (my usual size) and it was a tight fit! I then ordered 8.5 Wide as well as 9 Medium. When I got those, both felt great! I returned the 8.5 Medium. I decided to keep both the 8.5 Wide and the 9 Medium. The 9 is slightly larger, but still feels great. These shoes feel very comfortable. There is a cushion inside which is soft and I can wear these shoes all day. Style is very nice and I like how they are fashionable for work.

I wear 7M and this shoe in 7M was a good fit. I will replace the insole with something softer as I don't need the extra arch support. Fortunately the insole is removable. I have a bunion which the shoe accommodates quite nicely. The overall distressed and western look of the shoes make a perfect companion with jeans. Very comfortable for walking. The brown color is unusual but quite adaptable to any color pants.

I loved the look of these shoes, but there was so much inner sole cushioning that my regular size felt too tight. It was not in the front to back sizing; it was that my foot was pushed up into the top of the shoe, thereby squeezing my feet. It is unfortunate they didn’t fit as they had a great casual look. Well made too. But the sizing will be tricky.

So soft and comfy, and look great. I like the loafer look and these are holding up well with all the walking I do.

These shoes are super cute. BUT the soles leave dramatic black scuff marks. I'm having such a hard time deciding if I want to keep them or not.

I love this shoe, it is cute and very cushioned. For me, the 7.5 was so big my foot slid around, and the 7 was too tight, especially across the instep. There was also a very loud cracking sound in the left shoe when I walk coming from just behind the ball of the foot where the shoe bends. D coded not to try a third time.

Cute and seemed to be well made. Would be really cute on someone with a slender ankle. Looked a bit too “old Italian grandma” on my big ankles. I could have done with a bit more width but were it not for the matronly ankles I could have lived with the width.

the toe box was long, i could have lived with that as they were very attractive for a casual dress shoe. what i could NOT live with was how bad they hurt my heel and very quickly wore blisters on both my heels.

beautiful shoes and i wanted them to work.... the toes were too long for my normal 8W size but i could have lived with that.... within a few minute of wearing them in the house, they wore blisters on my heels. I'm not used to that and didnt want to get used to that.

These were so close to exactly what I was looking for! A simple black oxford that looked good for work but felt like a sneaker inside. I like the slip on style, and the elastic was great for my high instep. The footbed was extremely comfortable with excellent support for my high arches, once I managed to get the shoe on. I have medium-to-wide feet and the wide width was out of stock in my size so I took a chance on the regular width. Perhaps they would have loosened up with time, but out of the box the leather is a bit stiff and I almost needed a shoehorn to get them on, leaving no room for even a thin sock. So regretfully I will be sending these back, and hoping to find them in a 9W somewhere.

I ordered this in my usual size 8.5 M and they definitely felt a half-size too small. Unfortunately, when I went to re-order a 9, Zappos didn't have them in stock so I had to look elsewhere. These are some super cute shoes though! I love the cap toe, the slip-on style, and the stitched detailing. These shoes will look great with skinny jeans. I highly recommend - just think about ordering up a half size.

Bummer it is too small. Since there are no laces it is important it fits right

These felt awesome on due to the cushioning. They also provided moderate arch support! I have never worn Earth shoes before, so I was guessing on the size. I am usually a wide but for this shoe manufacturer, the wide was too big. I had to return since they kept falling off in the ankle area. I recommend these shoes even though they didn't work out for me.

I have these shoes in brown and they are AWESOME! I get so many compliments on them, even from my hip 30-something nieces, which is nice since I'm 58. They are super comfy and stylish. That being said, I ordered them in black, but I don't like the black nearly as much. The main reason--the heel. They have a mock stacked heel, which doesn't look bad on the brown shoe, but is much more noticeable as being fake on the black. I'm disappointed. I will be sending back the black pair and ordering a second pair of brown.

I typically wear size 8, normal width. The Blythe 8 fit, but felt bit tight in width if I wore a semi-thick sock. I put thinner socks on and it felt good. I like the look, leather, and arch support.

Super comfy, just not a fan of the round toe!

These are beautiful shoes. However, they are too narrow for my wide feet. Had to be returned.

Size 7-1/2 was fine but the arch insert did not fit properly in one of the shoes and irritated my foot. Was closer to the heel of my foot, not the arch. For the price, the product should have been better.

Slightly tight in the toes, but since this is genuine leather feel like will likely break in. Really comfortable! Only disappointment was the elastic inset in the middle, which made my tights pull and look strange.

Cute shoes but slightly short. Sending back.

I normally wear 8.5W, so bought that and these fit great. I have a fairly wide forefoot, normal heel, and very low arch. These are so comfy. However, I really absolutely hate the whitewash they put on the heel. It is MUCH more pronounced in reality than in the picture. It makes it look so cheap. Yet, these are so comfy. So, I'm going to try and find something to tone down the whitewash on the heels.