Customer Reviews Clarks Sharon Dolly

So I returned an 8 wide (navy with white sole) because they were too loose all around, for a 7.5 wide (navy, tan welt with black sole) and that pair I can barely get on, with a nylon stocking! Not sure what's going on here, maybe mis-marked??? I have other Clark shoes (with laces) all in 8 wide and they fit perfectly, but I wanted a slip on shoe for ease in putting them on. Guess I may have to stick to laced shoes, though I am awaiting a couple of other slip-on styles from Clarks.

So disappointed I had to return these due to sizing. These shoes were beautiful, seemed very well made, loved the color and the material was nice and soft. I usually wear a 11.5 wide, which is a tough size. I ordered the 12 wide in these, and my toes were scrunched up on the toebox, just not long enough for me. So I'm still searching for a comfortable pair of dressier work shoes - ugh.

I can't believe this was a size 11. It was way too small. I think I would have like the shoes, but I need to return them.

These shoes were just what I was looking for, however, they didn't fit. Clark shoes are usually too narrow for me, so I ordered Wide in a size down. Sadly, the heel kept slipping off even when I wore thick socks. So disappointed! Will have to return them.

awkward something wrong with this shoe....

To narrow

Too tight

Despite ordering my usual Clarks size, these were too long; my heel slipped out with every step.

This was a beautiful shoe in person and I regret having to return it. I have recently purchased other Clark styles in a 9.5 and they all fit comfortably. But this pair would have been tight, even without socks. I'm not sure even going to a wide would have helped, as the tightness as everywhere...not a lot, but enough to question their comfort for my size. With Zappos' return policy, I'd recommend ordering two sizes and keeping the one that fits.

These were too tight in the heel for me. The top of the back of the shoe rubbed my skin uncomfortably. I won't keep anything anymore if I have to break it in.

They did not fit at all! I ordered my usual size and I could not get my foot in the shoe. I ordered another pair of Clark’s shoes and they fit perfectly. The sizing is way off.

I love the look of this shoe, I was so disappointed I order an 11 w and they were a full size to small! So back they go and they do not offer a larger size!

I normally wear a 7.5 M, which is what I ordered. They looked adorable, but I could tell that the pointed-toe would be uncomfortable to wear all day, and the elastic step-in was just tight enough on my high instep that I didn't think I could make these work for walking and commuting on public transit. If these fit you, you will be thrilled. Really attractive shoes.

Super cute and comfy but run big. I think may be 1/2 size big so ordering 9.5. Hopefully won’t need a 9. I’m usually a size 10 in every shoe.

I consistently wear Clarks in a 7M. These shoes were narrow in the toe box and pressed uncomfortably on my high instep. The suede was beautiful, and the sole was comfortable.

These are beautiful shoes and I'm sure they would be so comfortable but I had a really hard time with the fit. I ordered my regular size 6 in a medium width and they were much too tight across the top of my foot so I returned them and ordered a size 6 wide, then those fit great across the foot but they slipped up and down on my heal when I walked. Was going to try one more time with a 51/2 W but they are out of stock! So sad because I really liked them.

These run very narrow!! and I have a some what narrow foot especially in the heel area. I ordered these thinking they would be to wide but it was totally opposite. But if I went a half size up they would just flop on my heels. Very disappointed

I should have paid more attention to other reviewers. These shoes are cute, but i ordered medium width and they were so wide Ithat my heel came out of the shoes completely with each step.

I really liked this shoe! The 8 wide was too small. The 8 1/2 wise was still too small - narrow in the toe box. Back they go. Too bad!

The shoe was really cute but the fit was off. I have a narrow heel and foot but normal size toe box area and if I went down a half size, it would of been tight in toe box.

I was excited to see a wide width exists in these shoes, but didn’t realize that I would need to size down more than a half size in order for these to fit. I don’t usually order a wide width, but my foot with a bunion feels cramped in a medium width unless it’s a very stretchy or mesh fabric. So my usual size is 7.5 medium in order to fit my orthotics. Because I knew the orthotics wouldn’t fit into these shoes, I ordered a 7 wide. They were massive in both length and width. Do wide widths mean wide in the heel as well? I’m not an experienced wide width shoe buyer. Rather than order a couple more sizes (would a 6.5 wide still be too big, or even a 6.5 medium?), I gave up on reordering. I need to be able to try these on in person. I love the style and the colors are great. I’m so frustrated with the sizing.

These are so incredibly cute and supportive! I did send back and ordered a wide and I’m hoping those will be more comfortable as the toe box in these was tight just because of the style of the shoe. Can’t wait to receive the wide and see if that increases the comfort. So excited to wear these with slim dress pants!

This shoe is very nice but is to snug on my foot. Sadly I am returning them.

Very difficult for me to rate this shoe other than on style. Nice looking shoe, I wanted it to fit however, the 7&1/2 was too short while the 8 was too long. I have come to the realization that I cannot wear Clarks, much to my chagrin.

I am looking for comfortable shoes when traipsing around traveling. I pretty much always wear a 7.5M in shoes and ordered that even though reviews indicate they run small. I'll have to send them back bc the toe box is just too short (my toes touch the front of the shoe). they fit like a glove on heels and on the sides ... which is ok if you want to go without socks, but there is no room for socks in these. Sadly neither the 8M or 8W was available. Too bad! Yes they are a bit clunky looking compared to shoes i normally wear, but they were SOOO comfortable! Oh well ...