Customer Reviews Naturalizer Jessie

Great boot, just didn't work for me.

Too tight around calf

These boots are very nice. However, the calf portion of the boot are designed for much larger legs than I have - I'm 5'6" and 144 pounds. Unfortunately, they have to go back. If you have larger sized legs, then these are the boots for you.

I’ve bought these in the past-but they’ve changed. This pair was more stiff and the color has changed.

You did not disclose that the wide width also ment a wide calf. I need a wide she fit not calf. Very dissapointed. Nice boots.

The color was not quite as rich as in the photo and the boots were massively wide around calfs.

I really loved the color and style but sadly the were too small. I ordered my regular size but they run small.

I LOVED these boots and was disappointed that they did not fit. (LOVED the color of the leather, the hardware - buckles & straps) Had difficulty with the zippers sticking.

I WANTED these boots to fit because I LOVED their look. (color, hardware - straps, & buckles) Was disappointed when they did not work. Zippers got stuck or were difficult to move.M

I normally wear a size 7 so that was the first size I ordered. I knew they would be uncomfortable because they felt too tight, especially in the toe width area so I returned them. I ordered a size 8 and tried on the right boot. It felt ok. Tried on the left boot and immediately felt it wasn't right. It felt like the boot was actually a size 7 but was marked as size 8. The two boots felt noticeably different. Even the 8 wasn't roomy enough to be comfortable so I returned them. I liked the style of the boot so it is too bad. There is not a good explanation of the width sizes. You can choose between M (B), W (C), and WW (E). It would be helpful to have an explanation of the differences.

I was so sad these boots didn't work out because they are super cute, and hugged my calf perfectly (not too wide or slouchy like a lot of tall boots), but the shoes were wicked narrow, and since my toe bed is wider than my heel, the shoe fit well in the heel but was much too tight in the toe bed. Because it was soft leather, it accommodated my high arches (also hard to find in tall boots), but was so tight around the circumference of my foot that I worried that would have worn out quickly. Also, the shoes had no arch support at all. Overall, the shoes run small and narrow, so probably go up a size if you want to get these - I will be returning and not reordering a larger size since I want better arch support.

The shaft was huge. Double-checked to make sure it wasn’t a wide-shaft. Nope. I could fit my entire arm in with my leg Had to return. Too bad. They are cute and seemed comfy.

Banana bread color was nice, and style was cute, but the 5.5M was very tight across the instep and in the toe box; I may have needed a wide width. Arch felt too far forward for me. The standard boot shaft fit my leg nicely, but if you want to tuck in jeans or wear boot socks, it may be a bit too slim. My 3-yr search for a stylish & comfortable riding-style boot continues...

In need of a boot for wide feet. I don't really need a wide calf, but just because I went from a shoe to a boot, my foot didn't get more narrow. These boots were supposed to be wide in the foot and were quite narrow. Very nice boot but not as advertised so I have to send them back. Don't usually have this problem with Naturalizer so this is frustrating

Had to send this one back, the width of the calf was WIDE! Way to big for my daughter. Don;t know if this was a mistake or incorrectly manufactured.

I was looking forward to receive this pair of boots. As soon as I opened the box I knew the calf area would be too big. Way too big. The leather looks like plastic to me. They were very true to size and comfortable but I will be returning those.

I loved the way these looked, but they felt like an average width, not wide. Wish I could have kept them!

I really love these boots! The color and style are just perfect. They feel comfortable, however I did not walk around in them. The sad thing is that the boot shaft is far too big. I unfortunately wear size 12 shoes. Therefore shoe companies believe that all large feet mean large calves. They were about 2 to 3 inches too big in the shaft circumference (size 12 has an 18 inch circumference). I wish that Zappos would list the boot circumference with each size of the boot. It would save a lot of returning. I would totally keep these if the shaft circumference had fit better.

My feet tend to be a bit wide, but not exceptionally wide. I sometimes order wide and sometimes do fine with a regular width. Before ordering these shoes, I tried on some other naturalizer shoes (dress shoes) at a local store and the 8.5 M fit me fine, so I decided to order that in these boots. Well, they didn't even come close to fitting. They were very small. My foot felt squished in all directions. Needless to say, I am returning them.

My regular size 7 was too small - had to send back

Disappointed in these. They look really cute online, but did not fit great and also didn't look as nice in person for real leather. The leather is not very soft, and they were just disappointing overall and not super comfortable.

Really cute boots but the material around the ankle bunched when walking. Too bad they are going back because they fit nicely around the upper calf.

I ordered the tan or honey color. They fit fine in the 7 1/2 wide. The calf is the advertised 15 inches. being happy with the product, I decided to buy the same pair in black. When I tried them the right foot over my arch was very tight. The left fit fine, just like the honey colored ones did. I am returning them and may buy another to see if they will fit correctly. Havent decided yet.