Customer Reviews Naturalizer Jessie

Cute boot, but I was looking for something a bit more dressy.

Ordered a 6 Wide. The boot fit perfectly, but the shaft was too narrow to zip up. Had to return them.

Boots look very nice. Have received a lot of compliments. Can be dressed up or dressed down. But surprisingly uncomfortable and provide absolutely no arch support.

I've had wide calf tall boots before but these wouldn't zip up. I was disappointed.

The overall design is cute, loved the buckles, but I didn’t care for the textured leather. I ordered a wide foot (not leg), as I find Naturalizers a little narrow in general. The footbed was comfortable, but the boot shaft was too thick at the ankles and therefore indented. I’m on the short side, 5’1”, and the boot length was good on my calf; not too high. Sent them back because they looked bulky on me.

I ordered both the M and C widths and there was no difference. The circumference around the calves is also way too narrow.

The description on this shoes was everything I was looking for but the shoes feel smaller by half a size. So definitely get half size up. It feel moderately comfortable, nothing to write home about. I wish it had better arch support and more supportive and flexible soles. The zippers could be smoother and bette quality for the price. Overall, it's ok. Not sure what boots are great if a full leather, comfort brand shoes are this away. I'll keep them just because it's tiring to look for great boots at my price point which is about $100.

I ordered wide because I need extra room around my toes. The feet fit great, but the calf was so big it was ridiculous. Sending them back, unfortunately.

I just got these yesterday so haven’t had a chance to really test these, but I was expecting these to be a LOT more comfortable at the soles. Although it says it has N5 Contour and dual density cushioning, it is only very lightly padded; however, there was room enough to put a short cushioned insole with arch support which helped. The heel is low enough that I’m hoping they will be comfortable at work. Cute style and nice color in “banana bread”. Zappos ships crazy fast, I ordered in early afternoon and received the next day, incredible!!!

Unfortunately, the zipper was slightly defective (it would stick in a few places) so I had to return these. I decided not to exchange for another pair because in a quick walk up & down the indoors stairs in my house (my typical test for footwear), I noticed these cut into my ankle and were uncomfortable. They are cute though and the shaft was pretty snug, which are both plusses in my book, fwiw.

I love them but I downgraded the star rating because the left boot is defective. It is too tight across the top of my foot. I didn’t notice until I wore them outside and it was too late to return them. :( I have small calve muscles and the boot fit snug like they are supposed to.

Lovely well-made boot. Sadly they were too tight both in width nd over the arch and too wide at the calf, so they're going back

I just wrote a review, but I mentioned that I didn't like where the ankle buckle was placed. I need to correct this, because I was mixing that up with the Born Poole boot. The buckle was in a great place, but the leather felt a bit cheap.

these boots looked great out of the box. They also fit well and were fine with my average size calves, with room to wear my pants inside them. I'm not keeping them because of 2 reasons - I found the leather to lack in smoothness, and I didn't like the placement of the ankle buckle, although I am always seeking the perfect boot (for me), and I think most people would not find this to be an issue.

I've been searching for a replacement for my Born boots to wear to work; I kept these because they are comfortable, and I've been looking for a long time with no success. The style of these boots in person is not quite as cute as the photo - the black leather is very heavy and shiny looking - it is not a soft, supple leather. They are the most comfortable pair that I have tried though, so, this is it!

Overall, I think this is a good boot for very casual wear. The quality of the leather is about right for the price, but I'm not confident it will hold up for more than one or two seasons. The finish of the leather is matte (vs. shiny) so they're not dressy at all. They are very comfortable--I could definitely wear them all day. However, I do recommend ordering a half-size up. I wear a size 9 M and they fit, but I couldn't wear them with anything but tights or a very thin sock. If you're looking for a very casual, comfortable boot and have narrower calves, this is a decent option.

Was a nice looking boot. . But didn’t have much arch support. Also seemed narrow. Had to return.

Was hoping for a good wide fit in feet area but still too narrow. Already sized up and too long. Bummed.

The toe pinched my foot. The shaft was too tight.

These fit fine but were too wide at top for even my chubby calves. I usually have to get wide-calf size but this was excessive even for me. Have to return, sadly, but they were otherwise great!

Nice looking boot.

I have never tried on shoes/boots that fit as bizarrely as these. I am a medium width and have never had trouble with shoes marked M. These were too narrow in the footbed and way too wide in the heel. Despite the uncomfortable tightness across my foot the boots flopped around on my feet when I walked. The calf circumference was good.

Usually Naturlizer "wide" width shoes are great for my feet but these were terrible, they did not feel wide at all. They squeezed my bunions immediately and i couldn't even wear them for 1 minute.

I loved these boots. The fit was perfect and I loved the style. The problem was a broken zipper on the right boot. I would have exchanged them but you no longer have the same size and color.

Was excited to try these based off of other reviews. Initial thought when I picked them up was they felt like hard plastic and not leathery. The zipper didn’t smoothly go up or down and the toe looked like it was air brushed for aging effect…badly air brushed. Super disappointing