Customer Reviews VIONIC Caroll

I have only worn the shoes once since receiving them. However, I love the workmanship and the overall quality of the shoe. They are the perfect shade of navy for me, not too dark, not too light! I have neuropathy, so my comfort level will be very different from most; however, I was happy with the fit and expect them to be even better after they have been worn a few times.

Great all-around flat. It’s very comfortable. It works with dressy pants as well as jeans. And, dresses, too. I have both black and navy.

I didn’t want to spend this much for a pair of simple ballet flats but I’m at the point in my life where foot comfort is priority, and these are the most comfortable flats I’ve ever worn. The toe box doesn’t pinch, they have cushioning and arch support, and the heel doesn’t rub or slip - amazing! They’re a little plain-Jane and perhaps slightly “dowdy” but at age 57 having injured both ankles I’m most interested in support and stability.

I accidentally selected that these fit too large on Zappos, but I meant for the other shoe in my order! These shoes actually fit perfectly right out of the box. I ordered my usual size 8 in the Wide option being that I have bunions requiring a wider toe box in flats. I like that these shoes have a wider toe box, but still fit normally through the heel. Some wide shoes come with a wide heel also and end up just slipping around with skinny ankles. The leather is soft, and the elastic trim around the foot is comfortable while looking decorative. No toe cleavage and doesn’t rub on the big toe bunion. I’m not in love with the style in person - they look a bit too much like a slipper to me in person than a nice work shoe option as they appear online. However, they are so comfortable that I’m keeping them anyway. I work on a very large campus so I have to walk a lot every day, but I have to wear business clothing. High heels are not an option with how much I have to walk. I’d say the arch support is more moderate than true support, and is placed too far back to get the full arch. However, my foot doesn’t roll inwards wearing these so they accomplish the goal. No pain in my heel after walking all day in these either with the true insole. I’ll be ordering more styles from the Vionic brand in the future!

They fit fine. I have bunions so they are a little tight in my toes, but to be expected. The leather is a little forgiving so it helps accommodate my toes. Very nice looking shoes. Have some arch support which I also need.

I tried a 6W, which was a little snug, and a 6.5W which had enough room without my heel slipping. I was concerned they might stretch, so I wasn’t sure which size would work - it turned out too be the 6.5W. I wore the 6.5W for the first time on a trip to NYC and walked miles and miles the first night. These shoes were PERFECT! I have never had a shoe so comfortable! Wore them again touring museums in Washington DC and, again, they were perfect and I could walk miles. I loved these shoes so much, I have bought another pair because I wore out the first pair. I have since bought them in another color, as well.

I purchased these shoes in black and liked them so I ordered them in the tan color too. They are comfortable and my Podiatrist says they are good for my feet.

Best shoes ever. I have a high arch and wide feet. These were perfect.

I ordered the 8W available, but must return for my usual 8 1/2 W. This is a cute shoe and the elastic keeps it from gapping. Reordering and willing to wait for this comfort!

First bought the pink ones, which I love, love, love! Wore them for the first time while facilitating an all day staff retreat - so comfortable, I never thought about my feet one time. So I bought a second pair in black. I would buy these in almost every color of the rainbow if I could. Please, Vionic, make more!

This is a very comfortable show right out of the box. I returned it because it seemed just a bit too short For my regular size 9.5 m. A good casual shoe not very dressy but could be good in a casual office setting.

I ordered these shoes in the soft pink. They are so pretty. The contrast trim dresses the shoe up. The toe box is comfortable. The cut across the top of the foot avoids the tender big toe joint. Heels feels great. I normally wear a 5.5. but had to order these in a 6. Feel good coming out of the box. I am wearing them to work!

Based on reviews, I ordered this shoe in my regular 8 and an 8 1/2 not knowing which would fit. The eight fit well in length and width.

The first day I wore them, the left shoe rubbed a bit at the ankle (probably don’t start by wearing them for a full day of work). However, ever since, they’ve been great! Moderate arch support and comfy to run around in all day. The gray wasn’t quite as gray as I’d hoped but still very cute and stylish.

This was my first pair of Vionic flats, I’ve only bought sandals in the past. They felt a bit too big, which I could lived with. However the back of the shoe comes up a bit and was uncomfortable and irritating for me. Will continue to search for a comfortable pair of Vionic flats, unfortunately these are not them.

The fit is what I expected for my regular size of 7.5. My foot runs a bit wide with a high arch and high instep. The arch support is adequate but nothing like a Birkenstock. The heels wear down quickly- I’d prefer a better quality sole that doesn’t wear so fast. I have these in 3 colors and found after accidentally stepping in a puddle that water stains the lighter leather (beige). Recommend a leather sealer prior to wearing. Overall a good comfortable flat.

I am between and 6.5 and 7 so I bought both. The 7 slipped in the heels and was a bit too wide through the foot so I knew it would give me blisters. I am keeping the 6.5 for now....trying to decide if it is indeed comfortable enough because these are super expensive. The toe box is a bit tight but I assume it will stretch with time. Cute, neutral flat.

Returned these shoes because they rubbed my heel. Bought Matira Vionics instead. Just as cute but much more comfortable and seemed to give better arch support.

It’s nice, and fits like other Vionic flats. It’s kind of sparkly, so keep that in mind. I think I’d have liked a little more if a matte type look, but otherwise, it’s a really good shoe!

These ran smaller than the vionic sandals I normally wear and just didn't work for me.

I love the comfort of these shoes and have bought multiple pairs. The problem is they last about a year which isn’t long enough based on the price!

Fit well. But comfort was not equal to prior vionics. They have also not worn as well as past Vionics I have purchased. I am a long time Vionics customer and am disappointed.

The arch support is excellant! I have a tailor's bunion, so a wide toe box is needed. The width of the tow box met my needs, and the heel fit nicely, but the middle sides gapped. I ordered the tan. The color was a perfect neutral.