Customer Reviews TOMS Paxton Water-Resistant Slip-Ons

I've wanted these for months but really didn't NEED another pair of shoes. I finally broke down and bought the gray ones. I'm a size 11, I sometimes buy wide shoes because my foot is wide and flat. From the reviews, I really didn't think they'd fit but I was wrong. They fit perfectly, the right foot around the top is just a very tiny bit tighter than the left but it will stretch...not so tight that I couldn't wear them comfortably. They are so adorable, soft and snuggly. I tried them on with socks and they fit fine and then without and they are like slippers. The arch support is perfect for my flat foot....the length is perfect, they don't slip at all. I'm blown away by how comfortable they are. Very true to my size 11. Really happy that I got them...they are perfect shoes for jeans, leggings or with pj's. Love.

LOVE the style but they are kind of tight across the widest part of my foot. The back also seems like it might give me a heel blister. So sad bc they are adorable but unfortunately they are going back.

I have had these shoes for a little over a month now and I have worn them almost every day. Something unexpected when I first got them was that the plush lining actually makes them quite snug, so they wouldn’t fit well with thicker winter socks. But that turned out to be fine because they are warm enough on their own. I have gotten horrible chilblains on my toes for the past few winters, and these have kept my feet warm and toasty and prevented that from happening! Texas winters aren’t cold enough for winter snow boots, and I’m not a fan of the chunky ugg boots look. These were the perfect combo of warm and stylish.

I originally ordered these in my usual size 7.5 straight from Tom's and returned them because it was SUCH a pain to get the shoe on my foot because of how tight the opening is and my foot felt a tad cramped. After not being able to find a similar style in any other shoe that had a little bit of character like this one does, I decided to reorder in a half size up. I have NEVER worn a size 8 but these fit perfectly. I can get the shoes on super quick and so far after wearing them for a few weeks, it doesn't seem like it's going to stretch out to the point that it will flop off my foot. I love these for everyday running around. They feel a bit more modern than my old Steve Madden black slip ons.

These are really cute and comfortable. I wear a size 8 in TOMS Classics so I got the 8 in these and they are about 1/2 size too big. But I do not intend to return them as the extra room doesn’t bother me. Even with thick socks they are a bit big but still comfy. I’ve had no issues with slipping or blistering.

These shoes were VERY tight when I first tried them on. The length was perfect but it was so hard to get the shoes on. Once my foot was in, the shoe felt good. PLEASE WEAR THEM FOR A FEW MINUTES. I’m so glad I did because they stretch out quickly. They don’t stretch too much, just the right amount. I really love these shoes and I’m so glad I didn’t send them back.

These are awesome easy winter slip ons- I added ugg footbeds so I didn't need socks! Perfect for the days you don't need boots but yet it's winter and gross out!

The Paxton blush is light pink, not a tan/blush neutral. It is definitely very pink. I was not expecting such a pink shoe as the color looks way more neutral to me in the pic. Returning for the brown suede.

I just got these in forged iron with the faux fur lining and absolutely love them! They are so snuggly and comfy. I don't know that I think they are super stylish, but I love them! I have already received lots of compliments and have sent the link to many friends. I am considering ordering the lighter birch suede!

Love Toms and the style of these but they’re just too narrow. Canvas Toms usually have enough give to accommodate for slightly wider feet but the suede on these makes them a little more snug and less stretchy I think. I did wear them around the house for two days to see if they’d stretch but it wasn’t much. Side by side picture of canvas Toms vs. these in the same size to show the difference in the give and how much longer these look.

These shoes are super cute! They were what I thought I was looking for...kinda sneaker, kinda shoe... They are perfect for wearing cropped or full length leggings or jeans, but they are uncomfortable. They are difficult to put on for starters and have no arch support at all, not to mention that the bottoms feel very stiff. I usually could sacrifice comfort for style but this time around I returned them. I was in need of an everyday comfortable and stylish shoe, but these did not fit my expectations as far as being able to just slip them on and be comfortable.

Size is true - I usually wear an 8.5 and these fit perfectly. These are so comfy, cute, and easy to slip on and off! Highly, highly recommend. I haven't worn them outside yet to test the water-resistant suede, but I'm sure it's great quality.

I usually wear a 5.5. I wish I had bought a 6 in these shoes. They are VERY tight. I tried them on with a thin no show sock and they became even tighter. As I wore then they did stretch out to a more comfortable fit, but had to take them off after an hour. Due to the lack of arch support I would have liked to have bought a shoe insert, however due to how tight they are that will not be possible. I'm going to keep these shoes because I'm hoping that as I wear them the will loosen up like most Toms do. However, if I were to get another pair I would go up a half size. Overall they are a cute shoe and look forward to wearing them.

I don't know how to review these shoes since I have very high arches and thus wasn't able to get the shoes on at all. They seemed nice and looked great, I just couldn't try them on. Fellow folks with pes cavus- these are not for us!

Super comfy, tts: at first felt slightly narrow to my oh-so-wide feet, but after the first few hours of wear shoe quickly broke-in. Perfect to wear without socks - just right for early springtime. faux-fur collar around the ankle feels so snuggly. Btw: Color is more steel grey than depicted on web site.

I have the black pair in this style and love them. I wear them to work and on the weekends too. They are warm and I love that I can slip them on and off easily. This new pair have soft faux fur on the inside (just the sides, not the bottom) I'm looking forward to wearing them!

Shoe seems about 1/2 inch longer than a normal size but ordering down would likely make it too narrow for me. It’s a quality shoe and great looking but not good for my slightly wider foot

Loving these shoes! Another reviewer said she replaced insoles w sheepskin fur insoles - I did the same and love how warm and cozy they are now and that I don’t have to wear socks. Super cute and the gray color goes well with everything.

Love these shoes! They are so cute! They fit perfect. Warm inside. You can wear with or without socks.

Love these things! They’re so soft and so snazzy!

Comfy and slips on easily.

These are my go to shoes now! I love suede and it has held up nicely! I has a nice sole and the water-resistant is a plus! No wet socks :)

Perfect just like my other 2 pairs of Toms. I am a size 5 or 5.5 generally. I ordered these in a size 5 Just like my other pairs of Toms and they fit great. I have a hard time finding shoes that fit me and are comfortable. I have a narrow foot and my right foot is about a quarter size bigger than the left. It certainly isn’t noticeable by appearance, but I can tell a noticeable difference when trying on shoes. So far this hasn’t been an issue with Toms. These shoes seem like they will be comfy all day and they also give a little lift. Very stylish look with jeans ur khakis and there is a warm sheering type material on the inside around the ankle that prevents any uncomfortable rubbing on the heal area.

I wear an 8 in the Toms Avalon that you wear with no socks. I was worried 8 wouldn’t leave enough space for socks. But, the 8 fits perfectly with socks. Guess they took that into account when they sized them. Super comfy! Love these shoes! Almost feel like slippers.

Bought these in navy for a Fall shoe, I like the grainy fabric and style.