Customer Reviews Columbia Minx Shorty III

Not warm enough, not comfortable. I got disappointed.

I wore these boots in snow and rain. They held up for awhile, but now they are leaking along the rubber sole seam, so they are useless for winter wear. Very disappointed as I otherwise really like the fit, comfort, and look.

Shoe fit terrible. I sent it back. Still waiting for my money

I'm a 19-year-old college student who had to attend class in -8 degree weather. I was outside for 15 minutes and managed to get frostbite on over half of my toes. I wore thick socks too, and with no covering, you can get frostbite in 10 minutes in this weather. Horrible...

I work outside and I thought these boots would be great for that and I was so disappointed. First of all my toes are freezing in them at like 35 degrees. Also the seams are coming undone and my feet were soaking wet and cold for my 12 hour shift. Also if you walk inside and your shoes are a little wet you are slipping and going down. All around bad shoe.

Thought these were super cute looking boots but the love ended once I put them on. The fit was too small and tight even with thin socks so I returned them immediately.

Even the wide is too narrow. The toebox of this boot is extremely small. I bought them and was worried about the size even though I sized up. I wore them around the house to test the fit and within 30 minutes my toes were squished. To keep feet warm you need air. Even the wides weren't the correct.

I ordered half size larger in hopes they would fit my wide feet and thick socks. They are too tight even with thin socks. Do not recommend if you have wide feet.

Too small and narrow. Price too high! Wouldn't recommend

Runs small and the overall feel was odd/uncomfortable

The 6 wide was definitely too small and not wide. That wasn't enough text to submit. Soooo I have purchased several coats. But the boots sizing is wacky.

Ordered this boot for my daughter and me in our usual size ranges--8M and 7.5W for me, 5M, 5.5M, and 6M for her. Every single pair was WAY too small--too short as well as too tight. All of the next logical sizes for us to try in the color of our choice (black) are sold out. So disappointed--seems like a great, lightweight but warm boot with great traction. We just had a huge snowstorm and am really disappointed that we are unable to use what would otherwise be the perfect boots for us because of the fit and product availability issues.

My daughter brought me these boots for Christmas only because I have worn Colombia boots for work and they were very warm and comfortable. These boots are not warm at all I work outside and came home with my feet frozen very disappointed... if I could send them back I would..

I would have loved to have rated them 5 stars but due to the fact that I have been waiting 3wks for my boots..I can only rate them based off of delivery..and that my dear has been a sh@@ show...heckthe winter might be over before I get them at this rate.

I had to call customer service - spent 4 hours and 32 minutes on hold just to hear that I can't change or cancel my order! I do not recommend ordering online.

These are very disappointing. Feet get wet in all but the driest Colorado snow. Tossing them in the trash.

dont fit for every body even when it is wide or not

Very disappointed. These boots are definately not Wide.

Runs small andbia way too tight on width and in toe box. I am a 10 and ordered a 10. Returned. Also seemed kinds cheaply made.

NOT wide as advertised. Way to tight. I wanted to wide shoe. I wish they made these shoes wide.

The company sent the wrong size. So i had to send them back