Customer Reviews Columbia Minx Shorty III

I loved these boots when they arrived. Cute and lightweight. Unfortunately I had to return them. I bought a size up and they were still too small. I am a size 10, got and 11 but my toes hit the end when I walked in them. This was the largest size. I couldn't find another pair of boots like this in my size.

These didn't work for me so I returned them. A bigger size may have worked but I didn't like them enough to do that with an online purchase.

They are warm and they fit as described. I'll keep these since it's hard to find flexible soled boots that don't rub me wrong or make my toes numb from being too tight with thick socks. However, I probably should have paid more attention to make sure they were compatible with gaiters. They aren't; they don't work with gaiters. No hooks or place for a strap to sit securely under the instep. Sometimes the snow is just way higher than these little 5in sides can handle and I was looking for a versatile boot. They are fine for running around town and walking in a little snow but aren't going to cut it for hiking or cutting through drifts on snowy days without the gaiter option.

These boots were great. Warm. Water proof. Then after some wear I noticed there is zero arch support and it causes me serious hip and back pain to wear for long walks. For the price this is very disappointing.

I bought these over a month ago. They're a little snug but fit and they are very comfortable. I love walking my dog in them. They do keep your fee warm. The only issue I have with them, they are wet after I come inside. I don't find these waterproof. I'm only out in the snow for 20-30 mins. When I put them on again they are a little wet.

I've had these boots for over a month now and I mostly love them! They are comfortable, warm, waterproof, and I sized up so I can wear any socks with them. My issue is that with the fur around the top, the boot doesn't seal around my leg so on really snowy days I kick snow down the top of my boot. For short walks with my dog it will work but if I was wearing them all day in deep snow it would be very cold and uncomfortable. I've tried to tie the laces as tight as possible but I can't avoid it.

One of the boots is tighter than the other and a bit uncomfortable to wear. The other one is perfect. This is just my experience, but great boot nontheless.

Took about 6 weeks to arrive and then they are too small and very tight around the toes. Very disappointed.

I like these boots because they are sleek, and not clunky. However, they are truly not waterproof, and no traction on the bottom. Very slippery.

I am going to return these because they are too small across my foot. I tried walking around in them in my house and it was squeezing my foot. I tried to loosen the strings but it still did not help.

Wish I could rate better but I'm rating on actually opening box, trying them on, and realizing that even though I ordered half a sizer bigger than my average, the shoes were too small. My toes touched the very tip. Not much cushion but it would have been nice.

I chose this boot for a trip to a place with temperatures below -35 C. The truth is that they are very comfortable, but the cushioning isn't the best for the protection against the cold, even at -20 C (when in theory, should hold up to -32 C). Out of that, I love the model.

These boots are really nice to look at, but unfortunately, they run way too narrow-even for a normal sized foot. Someone with a wide foot would never be able to get these on.

The description is incorrect and they aren't suede. These are all textile and a great vegan snow boot option for those with narrow feet. The length of the shoe runs true to size, but the reason they feel small is because they're so narrow. I normally wear a 7.5/8 but ordered a size 8 and 8.5 due to the reviews. The size 8 fits the length perfectly, but is uncomfortably tight around the top of my foot. Forget about wearing thick socks. These shoes are for thin socks only. And the 8.5 is just way too long but fits the width. I'm keeping the 8 and hoping they stretch.

I love how these boots feel and look. They are very comfortable. They do not feel very warm and I didn't feel like the tread was enough to prevent a fall. I'm glad I got a 1/2 size larger so I can wear thick socks.