Customer Reviews Columbia Minx Shorty III

I ordered a 7.5 wide, and my toes were cramped. These boots are incredibly narrow. If you're between 7.5 and 8 and want to wear them with socks, you will have to size up.

I love the boot but it is too short. Toes hit the end, can't wear heavy socks. I am a 7.5 and I ordered an 8 for extra room but need a little more. Overall, nice boot.

Footbed is okay- but that’s only because the sole is non existent for walking on anything other than grass. Absolutely awful- can’t walk on cement paths or cobble stones. Not even w my own custom orthotics. I’m sure my feet wld be cold as the sole has no substance. Not even cheap gym shoe sole- worse than that. So sad as they are really cute shoes. Add vibrum soles and you will have a customer!!

This fit as described; the problem is that the footbed pushes to the 'inside' and the upper is not very stiff, so looks crooked when wearing, they have a very worn out look when they are on, the upper part should be more rigid to look like a proper boot.

Too small even though I am usually a 7.5 in Columbia. No support. Felt like I was wearing a glorified slipper.

These boots run small and narrow .. they're really hard for those with high instep as well

These boots are cute and actually fit well and were comfortable, but my foot rolled inward, so I knew this boot would not be comfortable to wear for long periods on my feet. Because of my overpronation, I need a wider support in the arch area of the sole. I'm sure this would be a great bootie for others.

Boots were not marked 'wide' and were too tight.

It is narrow in the toe box. I had to return

Very cute -- but unfortunately the wide is not wide. I'm a 7.5W -- and like a lot of women with wide feet -- I have a wider forefoot and an average width heel. So usually if I have a problem with a wide size it's because they slip in the heel. But these boots were narrow everywhere. To have space for thick socks, I ordered an 8.5W -- a full size larger than my foot size. I tried them on with athletic socks -- not even puffy wool socks -- and they barely fit in the forefoot and were too tight in the heel. And I couldn't size up any more because the 8.5 was already almost too long for my foot -- any larger and I would have been tripping in these boots. If the wide size fits this narrow -- the regular width must fit like an iron maiden....

Fit was fine and seems true to size. However, the style was very strange - the sole of the boot is really small compared to what it looks in the photo, the top is very wide and flat, and the result is that they look (to me) like ugly slippers. Returning!

These are thin on the sole, with no heel. Not enough support for walking in snow. They look great, though.