Customer Reviews Columbia Minx Shorty III

I ordered these boots with a doubt that they would fit, as I wear a size 12 in woman's and haven't had much luck in the winter footwear dept. These boots fit perfectly and are super comfortable, it's like walking on little cushions! These boots will keep your feet dry and help you keep your grip during Icy conditions. However, my toes still get SO cold while wearing them. I wore them with winter socks to a football game where the temp was 10 degrees real feel and by the end of the game I couldn't feel my toes they were that cold! I would still recommend these boots based off of comfort and the ability to keep your feet dry.

These are the first winter boots I've purchased in years. I ordered 1/2 a size up and they fit perfectly with thick socks. It hasn't snowed since I got them so I haven't been able to truly test them out but they are lightweight, stylish, and comfortable! I'm looking forward to stomping in the snow with them!

The sole of the shoes is designed to walk on snow so that it won't be slippery. The fluff in the shoes keep my feet warm even. The surface of the shoes is waterproof, any snow or ice attached to the surface will slip off quickly. However, the front part of the shoes is a bit too narrow, it would be too tight to wear thick socks in it.

It is of excellent quality and it is pretty warm and it makes walking through snow much easier. However, I have wide feet so when I wear thick socks, my toes are cramped inside the boots and my toes hurt after I wear it for the whole day.

I purchased these boots in October. For a typical winter and a normal amount of snow, they're warm enough with some nice, thick socks. For slushy snow, it's not easy to keep traction and I found there was some moisture leaking in. Definitely not rated for sub zero temps! Getting the boots on can be a struggle if you don't loosen them enough. My biggest complaint is that it's now April, just six months later, and the inner heel is coming apart.

I like the boot but it ran small to me, I am returning and getting next size.

Very comfortable and warm, but not very waterproof. Maybe for light drizzle or packed snow but not more than that. Based on reviews I got them for snowshoeing and within 30 minutes my socks were wet. Then it takes forever for the boot to dry from the inside. Not meant for outdoors.

Cute, warm boot, but it didn't provide enough support for me (flat feet). Unfortunately I had to send them back :(

These boots are super cute and stylish, but not the most comfortable. They seem to run small and are narrow as well.

These are comfortable and cute. The toe box is actually wide enough. However my feet did not stay warm at all outside for less than an hour in 46 degree weather so I'm very disappointed about that.

These boots are a beautiful color. I was disappointed that they are too narrow with tight toe box.

I needed a boot that is really comfortable for street-walking in the winter, and I was disappointed that these weren't more supportive. I feel like they need a shoe insert to be ideally comfortable. They were certainly warm, so that's good. I was also disappointed that the blue color wasn't nearly as vibrant as the photo is.

They were very tight, be sure to size up if you have problem feet such as bunions or arthritis in big toe.

They fit well for my wide feet and they're warm. The quality feels very cheap, I doubt they'll last 2 winters.

The boot is warm and I like the height, but the sole is not not supportive and they boots just feel off. I would not recommend for long walks. I have Baffin boots for long walks with snow & cold, but needed something short for going out and these work. I would not pay full price for these but I will keep them as I got them on sale and they are cute with jeans. I wish I had gotten them in a Wide as the front part is narrow.

I love the boots . Like the style . Size 8.5 fits good the only one thing is that they are not even and heal fells like it needs more support . I put shoe inserts and it kind of fix problem .. I will keep them