Customer Reviews Columbia Minx Shorty III

Boot fits true to size. D width is truly a 'D'. Toe is a little narrow but not bad. They are really cute.

I have a narrow foot so these are great.

I love these shoes. I am a true size 7, and these fit perfectly. They are super comfortable and cute. I received the shoes three days ago and I’ve been wearing them every day. I highly recommend the shoes!

These are like warm mittens for your feet! Wore them on a trip to British Columbia and my feet stayed warm and dry in cold drizzly weather. Great traction too!

These boots are really cute, and warm and cozy. Unfortunately they are too small, so I am returning them. I'm hoping Zappos has the next half-size up! I really like them.

These boots are incredibly comfortable. However, I'm glad I read the reviews and sized up. Normally I'd wear an 8.5/9, but I got 9.5 and they're perfect. These are warm, comfortable and stylish. I love the wine color.

Love these snow boots so much! I ordered them a full size larger and they fit great! They are so extremely comfy and cute. Best snow boots I’ve ever had. So happy with my purchase!

After reading the other reviews I ordered a half size up. I usually wear an 8.5 or 9 so I ordered the 9.5 which fits perfectly. They are very comfortable and warm. I ordered the blue and red and intended to keep only one pair. But both colors were beautiful and I like them so much so I am keeping both pairs.

These are the cutest and most comfortable little boots ever! I ordered a half size up per reviews and I’m so glad I did. They fit perfect! I ordered a size 10 and they don’t look huge. As a matter of fact they make my feet look small! Woohoo! Go for it. You won’t regret it.

These boots are great. I generally wear a 6.5/7 and ordered the 7 which fit me perfectly and I can wear them with thick socks. It hasn't gotten freezing cold here in Boston yet but so far these boots have kept my feet warm and they are very comfortable to walk in. I would highly recommend these boots for bus and subway commuters looking for stylish and comfortable boots.

I was looking for waterproof and warm boots to wear to Germany in December. I will be doing a lot of walking so I didn't want to aggravate my bad heel, but I know it will be cold and wet. I tried on a number of similar boots, including Sorel and Keen boots. These fit the best hands down. They are so cushy inside and very warm. In fact, I think I would have difficulty wearing them inside for any length of time without getting hot feet. I took out their substantial footbed and substituted my orthotics and they accommodated them perfectly, if I want to go that route. The ankle and foot weren't too binding - they were soft and quilted. I own Bean Boots and I find the stiff leather stresses my ankle if I walk in them too long. I did go up a whole size from street shoes. I wear an 8.5 or 9 in closed shoes and flats. I wear a 9.5 in Nike tennis shoes. The 9.5 boot fit, but I wanted plenty of room for thick socks, so I went with the 10. Although with the warmth of these boots, I may not need thick wool socks! I'm so glad I found what I needed for extended time outside that also will be comfortable to walk around in.

Cute boots, but they ran small. I'm between 9 and 9.5, I ordered a 9.5 and had to exchange for a 10.

I need a slightly HIGHER toe box and a little more support. If the sole was firmer - maybe that is all I would need. It comes with a VERY "cushy" insole. When I took it out: I realized that it really can NOT be replaced. It seems as IF that SPECIFIC footbed needs to be in the boot.

I ordered a size up like all the reviews said to do, but It was too tight in the toe box.

Nice boot but easily a half size to a full size small

I bought the blue ones. Very, very cute! Very warm and comfy! I did get a half size up because of the reviews and it fit. I'm sadly returning because the left one was off-center and made my foot turn toward the inside. Keeping the Sorels instead because of slightly better support.

I have a pair of Columbia Ice Maiden boots that I’ve been wearing for the last couple winters and love but they’re a bit heavy and clunky for just running errands. I ordered these because they still offer warmth and traction on snow or ice but they’re also super lightweight. They can fit under pants or over leggings. They do run small and narrow. I normally wear a 10, I got a 10.5 in my previous Columbia boots but had to get an 11 in these.

Great that these are thermal and waterproof, and have the faux fur lining and laces. I felt like the sole was a bit thinner than the Columbia Heavenly omni-heat shorty, and and the quilting on the boot ok but not as pretty as the Heavenly. Still, if I had kept these, I would have picked this one over the Heavenly as this Minx II can be worn over or under pants. Ended up sending both back because I chose a Sorel instead, but might get these in the future if they beef up the outer sole a bit.