Customer Reviews TOMS Carlo

Good fit, nice classic look. Goes with anything so it’s easy to dress up or down. Fits well and pairs good with slim fit and wide leg pants.

These are exactly what my husband was looking for. He likes thin shoes and that’s exactly what these are. He wears 14 in all other shoes- he’s never owned a pair of TOMS before so we still purchased a 14 and he says they fit great.

Comfortable all around

I'm in a 10 in most shoes. After reading the reviews, I ordered a half size down and quite honestly, I should have done a full size down. What kind of giant runs the sizing system at TOMS? Overall, I really like the shoe, they look great with a pair of jeans but honestly I still can't get over the fact they have giants running this company.

Loved the look of this shoe and it looks as good on as it does in pictures. These go well with jeans, shorts, however you want to dress them. The shoe is pretty stiff to start off and it really dug into my achilles for the first several wears. Also, I ordered an 11.5, as other Toms I have fit me very well at 11.5, but these do feel like I could have ordered a half-size down. Overall, I expect these to look great long-term, as they seem very durable, and I expect the comfort to only improve as I break them in further.

Too large to be comfortable

The style is great. However, it’s paper thing. Canvas shoes aren’t meant to be long lasting, but I think even Vans Authentic would double the life time of these.

Can’t give any legit stars yet but I’m normally a 12. 12 too big 11.5 too big I’m hoping the 11 will fit just right Will repost when size is right

Very little support/arch so not as comfortable for walking but style is very nice.

Shoe could have been very comfortable if it hadn't been so narrow at the toes. If you fit Converse, these also could be a good option.

After years of buying Toms shoes...this is my last ... fit is so different

Tom's do not fit the way they used to at all....they are now much larger.

The shoe looks nice but these were the first pair of shoes to give me blisters on my achilles. I wore no show socks due to the style of the shoe but you need socks a little taller to protect from blisters. Unfortunately the style of the shoe doesn't look amazing with different socks on me.

These shoes fit great, but returned them because I did not like the sneaker type style.

The shoes feel abnormally long. The shape was just a little weird. I might just be used to the traditional vans shape.

I went a half size larger to have more room in the toe box. The shoe was very long then, but still tapered very narrowly and without any extra room for toe spread despite the added length. Narrow, cramped toe box might relax a little since it is made out of canvas. I prefer the Cabrillo.

Super stylish shoe, decent price. NOT ideal if you're walking around all the time, more for easy weekend and light work/rec.

Like many sneakers of this style, there's a minimal footbed. I can live with it, but I've seen other styles that have a memory foam insert that's much cushier. They're not bad, don't get me wrong. The fit, finish and styler is good. I'm keeping them. But, I'll wish for memory foam inserts after a long walk, I'm sure.

Not comfortable and there wasn't enough room for an insole.

I got a 10.5 and the size felt right to me. I really like the look of this shoe. I was sad that I had to return it. It was too painful on my achilles.

The fit was way too narrow. I ordered a 10 and couldn’t get my foot it. Order an 11 after lots of measurements, and it was too big length wise, but still snug on the sides. I’ll have to go with another style even though these looked sick.