Customer Reviews SOREL Whitney™ Tall Lace II

I love these boots !!! The boots fit perfectly and feel great on my foot !! Very warm and great in the snow!!

I normally wear a size 7 in Sorel boots, but got these in a 7.5 so I could wear heavy socks. They are great. They are warm and keep the snow out.

After reading the reviews I went up a half a size. This fit perfect with a regular pair of socks. When trying on, this boot feels almost like a sneaker. Feel like it will be good for commuting and running errands in the snow.

I love these boots so much! Today is one of the first heavy snow days (Ohio), and I couldn’t wait to try out these boots in cold, wet, snowy weather. They definitely live up to the hype. They are super warm (but not too warm), comfortable, easy on, easy off, good traction, look cute, overall an ideal casual winter boot. Definitely order a half size to a full size up, depending on the thickness of your socks.

Absolutely love these boots! Warm, comfy, and cute!

I ordered a 8.5 since I have wide feet but they were narrow and tight on me. I had to exchange them and get myself a size 9. Other than that, they are warm and most importantly waterproof for this New England winter weather. Hope this review helps!

I ordered a half size up because of the reviews and they are perfect. The front of shoe was not tight as some reviewers mentioned and I don't have narrow feet. But I used regular and not thick socks. Love them,

These boots are everything I hoped they would be! I have an old pair of the "Joan of Arc" style Sorels and was looking for something that would be just as warm and waterproof, without being so clunky. These have completely exceeded my expectations so far, and are DEFINITELY less clunky than some of their comparable styles. Only issue- these run very small. I am typically a size 9, sometimes 9.5, but read a couple reviews on another site mentioning they ran small. I went with 9.5 and had to return them for a size 10!

Super cute boots - bought for my 13 year old daughter who wears a size 9 boot. We ordered multiple sizes - the length is about 1/2 size smaller but the toe box is also quite small so it just wouldn't fit (and she does not have a wide foot).

I wanted a warm, waterproof, lace-up boot that I could still easily slip into. I have 2 small dogs who need their walks no matter what the weather. I am really surprised at how lightweight these boots are. I like the lace-up rather than a zipper because I can make them tighter at the top and not worry about picking up small pebbles that can get kicked up and caught inside the boot. A lot of my zippered boots are wider at the top and this seems to happen a lot. Also helps keep out the snow and slush. I normally wear a size 6 but ordered a 6-1/2. Size 7 was just too floppy. Excellent fit with medium weight socks. I bought them in black and I actually like the laces-but they are easily changed if you'd prefer a different color. Very happy I bought these particular boots. Very comfy, very cute.

Warm and comfortable. Very light, easy to walk in it, not clunky at all. Have not tried in snow yet.

They fit well in the length and width. However, they were far too roomy in the instep area. I pulled the laces as tightly as possible, but there was still too much room and my foot wouldn’t stay in place. Liked the style and looked like they would have excellent traction. Lightweight and very comfortable to stand in - just didn’t fit my feet securely enough for walking in snow.

Finally got the correct size. One full size larger. Now they feel great, decent arch support. Going out in the snow soon to test!

The footbed was very comfy & I really liked these, except they were too small so I am returning. These boots don’t come in size 12. Normally I wear size 10.5-11.

Very nice looking boots I need more cushioning in the inside heel area for my feet

I absolutely LOVED these and Zappos got them to me so quickly. Unfortunately, even though I ordered the largest size I could (10.5, and I'm usually either a 10 or an 11 in boots), they were way too small. I went ahead and ordered a 12 from Sorel's website directly, which I was a little sad to do because I really like ordering from Zappos. But PLEASE be forewarned: this half size up felt like I was wearing an 8 or a 9, not a 10.5, especially on my right foot (which is a bit bigger than my left), but it was also too snug on my left. So if you're going to order these, and you're tall/have larger feet, definitely do not order your normal size. And besides, you want a bit of extra room so your feet stay warm and you have enough room for thicker socks if you need them. (I tried these on with very thin socks, btw.) Aside from the 10.5 being too small, I love love love how they look, how they feel, and how they could clearly be worn comfortably straight out of the box. I could tell that if I had the right size, they'd be absolutely perfect. The faux fur trim is super soft and will help keep snow out; the interior is nice and warm, and I noticed the insulation right away; the laces are thick, sturdy, and have great friction so you shouldn't have to worry about laces coming undone; tightening, loosening, and tying the laces is really satisfying somehow, like it's just really easy, unlike a lot of winter boots; the shell of the boot has a nice winter puffy-jacket feel to it while also being minimal and clearly functional; and the SOLE! Oh mY GOD the sole!! I immediately felt the difference between these and other boots I've tried because of the memory foam. They're so comfy on the bottoms of my feet. I can see myself walking quite a ways in these and not getting fatigued. I'm really excited for my larger size to come! I always have such a hard time finding good boots, and these are just fantastic. (Aside from being way too small, anyway.) If you take nothing else away from this review, take this: SIZE UP!!

Narrow and uncomfortable for my feet. I like the style but I have to return them.

I am a professional dog walker in NE Ohio. Keeping my feet dry and warm is extremely important during the winter months. These boots are lightweight, easy to walk in, however after a full day of walking (15,000 steps or so) they do start to get uncomfortable in the area where my arch is. Not unbearable but uncomfortable. Also, my socks do feel damp often, so they aren’t completely water proof. I wear 7.5 and ordered an 8 and glad I did. The style is very cute. Overall- a decent boot but not the best for keeping feet dry or warm when temps reach lower 20’s and under. It’s just so hard to find the perfect boot for all needs.