Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Waterproof XC4® Casual Dress Plain Toe Prentiss Sneaker

Good looking shoe

Great looking shoes. Comfortable while wearing and walking whether a little or a lot of activity. Shoe sizes have the same size on the label, but the right is noticeably smaller than the left, needs improvement in size QA/QC.

I was surprised the XW fit my 4e foot. They don't dig into the back of my heel like lower cut shoes. They don't breath very well and run awfully hot. I assume it's because they're waterproof. They would be great for when it's colder. My feet feel warm just sitting in the office. I wear athletic socks with them so maybe a thinner sock would be better. The comfort is very good and you can probably get away with much thinner socks. I wish they had more styles and colors in XW that were similar. I will likely buy another pair as soon as they're available. Mine were missing the stripped laces, those look nice and they don't stock them or sell them. I only got the laces in the shoes. We'll see how they hold up but I wore them for the first time and for about 11 hours.

I wore these in France and walked 5 miles a day for a week. They were extremely comfortable and waterproof which came in handy.

Great show. They run a size small. I sent the original order back and still awaiting the new pair.

once its on, very comfortable. would prefer shoe without "sock" insert. think it makes it difficult to slip on.

Great

Very pleased with the comfort and fit.

The shoe is nice looking and comfortable. My problem with this shoe is that it is VERY hard to put on!! The sock is the problem- it does NOT allow you to slip on the shoe. I must use a shoe horn! Why did you make it that way? I talked with one of your customer reps and they said they get many of the same problems.

A bit tight in the toe box area.

Well made, comfortable shoe. A bit tight fit initially, but expect that to disappear after more wear.

Comfortable on any surface. However, I sound like two pool floats rubbing together when walking on tile.

I had to remove the insert so the shoe would fit. I by no means have a wide foot, and every shoe I have ever worn has been D width. I know the shoe was designed to not lose any comfort with the insert removed, but common sense tells me that taking away the cushion of the insert does make a difference. It would be great to just make the shoe specific to one size, instead of trying to save money by utilizing a removable insert. That being said, the shoe is still a fairly comfortable shoe, even if it is a pain to deal with the spandex lining when putting on the shoe.

I usually look at what comes in a wide width (E, EE) to start my search when buying shoes. I previously bought these in the M/W width and removed the adjustable inner sole liner for the wide version. I found them to be a little tight and difficult to put on with the collar around the opening. I then reordered them in the extra wide width which also comes with a removable liner. This pair is a little easier to get on and fit me nicely with the foot liner in place. They're comfortable, but probably not what I'll wear for my mile and a half exercise walks.

I like this XC4 in blue, but I had to take the insole out for it to fit. The sales person suggested this, and the shoe is fine.

Are very comfortable shoes for every day night out and day

This line of shoes probably my favorite all time due to style, durability and comfort. I prefer the gray version to this black one (I have both) because I didn't realize that the black is fairly shiny and I would have preferred a matte black.

There is a comfort with these shoes right out of the box. They're light and stylish. While I like the minimalist, streamlined look, I'd like to get more traction from the sole.

Great looking, and comfy. Waterproof shoes always run a little warm though.

Because of the tongue design it's a little difficult to put on. Otherwise it's fine.

Very nice shoe but runs small to size.