Customer Reviews Franco Sarto Carolynn

I tried both this shoe and the Bocca. They are both lovely shoes and have a similar fit. This one, the Carolynn, has more personality and is cuter, I think. I have a bunion and I just don't feel confident the toe box is quite big enough to be comfortable. I might try a W - the shoe really is nice. Otherwise, I ordered my regular size and it seems right.

Great shoes

I purchased this shoe in black patent in my usual size 7 M. The first time I put them they were a little tight but after 5 minutes they felt great. I love the combination of the black with tan trim bottom. I will easily be able to wear these to work or casual. I plan on wearing these shoes with peds. If you are planning to wear them with socks you might want to consider sizing up in length or width.

True to size, looks great! I've received may compliments when wearing these shoes.

Love these patent loafers! They are cute and modern which is hard to find in loafers. I am a solid 8 and that size fit well. They were comfortable and easy to wear all day right out of the box (I wear small no show footies because they make my feet sweat). I love that they wear well in the fall and are the perfect rainy day shoe in warm weather. I have received many compliments wearing them. Love these stylish loafers! Thank you Zappos for great service and shipping.

Best business casual shoes I've ever owned! These shoes look classy and even though they are very structured, they were somehow comfortable from the very first time I wore them.. Not one blister/sore spot. I have them in both black and navy. You need these shoes!

Shoes are just as cute in person as they look online! Love them. Comfy and stylish. If you're between sizes, order down.

I love this shoe but order a full size smaller. I am a true 7.5 but needed a 7. Very comfortable.

The shoes fit very well. I love buying shoes from Zappo’s.

Love Love Love. At first from the photos I thought it would looked clunky and big but not at all. Very flattering on the foot.

Beautiful shoes. These are so cute!!! I was worried they’d be too chunky, but not at all. Cute with slacks, jeans or capris. They do run true to size, but very stiff. No give to the shape. If you typically order W, theses are not for you. I usually shift between a 9 1/2 to 10 medium, tops of my feet can get puffy, so these were a little too tight across the strap. But super cute!!!

Really shiny and really cute with leggings, jeans and dress pants. Comfortable with and without socks.

1runs big by 1/2 size

So cute and comfortable right out of the box. They look great with jeans and leggings. I love the tassel. Just a fun shoe.

These run a whole size larger than usual. They are beautiful leather, very shiny patent, very well-constructed.

Very well made and fits consistently to other Franco Sartos. They are a bit snug which I think is due the patent, but more comfy after a few days of wearing. Super cute and overall quite comfy.

So odd. I wear size 6. Size 6 is too large - I’m walking out of them. Size 5.5 is too tight. So I settled on size 6, and added an insole. Very adorable shoes though!

Fit is too large

After reading the reviews I ordered a half size larger. Unfortunately they were too large. True to Zappos great service, I called and had my replacement shoes the next day ready to leave on my vacation. These shoes are very comfortable and a great style. Thank you Zappos !

I have been looking for a loafer with a durable sole that was stylish and on trend. This is definitely the shoe. First day wearing them and they were still comfortable by the end of the day. I love these shoes!