Customer Reviews Sperry Seaport Penny

I like the shoe, but I can't even get it on in my normal size. Will try again with a full size larger.

you sent me an 8 and I ordered a 7 and half

Small couldn't get my foot in they went back immediately

They're not true to size. I ordered 6.5 my foot doesn't fit.

Why are you asking me to review a pair of shoes that I returned?

Beautiful shoe.. wish it came in wide. I unfortunately had to return them

To tight and small need to return. Will you send me information on returns. Thank you. Will reorder

I bought the "moccasin" style loafer in Black and Tan. So disappointed in the quality and leather. Kept the black, returned the tan. Nothing like the one I purchased in the past. They were well made with quality smooth leather. The new loafers look and feel as if the were made specially for discount department stores or factory outlets. Would not purchase again.

Nice shoe, great fit, however the left shoe was defective.

I've worn Sperry shoes for years, and they've always fit well and are comfortable. These were extremely narrow, so much so that I wasn't even able to get my feet in them. They were returned quickly.

I ordered a pair of these and the shoes tore up my heels.

Should have read the reviews about their small sizing. The sizing is absolutely too small and I was barely able to fit my foot in the shoe. I've gone back and forth with Sperry and have decided to find another brand of loafer.

TOO NARROW. I have 4 other pairs of Sperry's casual shoes and wanted a dress pair to wear for work. I wear an 8 M in 99.9% of my shoes. I very rarely purchase an 8.5, but due to the reviews on this shoe, I went with an 8.5. I was shoving my foot into the shoe only to experience a terrible and uncomfortable experience. Really????!!!! I am not going up another size, so off they go back to Sperryland. It is a shame too because I NEED a pair of shoes like this, and now I have to keep hunting. I am not sure what is going on with these shoes, but it would be great Sperry, if you could fix it!!!!!!

Please read the other reviews ladies!!!! These shoes are beautiful... I wear a size 12 narrow and could not even get my big toe in the shoe! Way too narrow. SPERRY needs to read their reviews and FIX the problems!!!!

I always wear a 9M in dress shoes, so that's what I purchased first. The shoe was so narrow I could barely get it on. There's no way the leather could have stretched enough to fit my foot. I returned it and ordered a 9W. It fit well across the front of my foot, but the back kept slipping off my heel. Definitely the weirdest sized shoe I've ever tried on. Super disappointed. It looked like it would have been very comfortable for work if it had fit correctly.

Had to return the shoe due to fitting one size too small. Could not do an exchange so I had to return shoe. Very skeptical about purchasing another pair.

I always wear 8.5 in Sperry shoes. I have different styles, boat shoes, boots, penny loafer.... I liked this shoe so much, but it's too small and narrow. I received them today and I can't wear them at all. Tried to order a larger size but they are gone.