Customer Reviews Sperry Seaport Penny

Love these shoes. Unfortunately they were too narrow so I returned them, hoping they will be available in wide soon,

I wanted to love these shoes as they are beautiful and the leather is soft and high quality. So, I wore them inside for a day in hopes of breaking them in. Unfortunately, my foot was deformed from this exercise and my achilles hurt for a couple of days afterwards. The shoes are way too narrow for a normal foot. I ordered a size larger in pink as well as my normal size in wide in a different color as the pretty dusty pink in the soft leather in not available in wide. The wide size fit me, but it is a different leather (not as soft) and not the pretty pink color. I am keeping it, but am quite disappointed that I had to return the pink shoes altogether. I would not recommend this style unless you know for a fact that you have a very narrow foot (in which case I suspect they will be as comfortable as beautiful!)

This is a super cute shoe, but it is definitely narrower than the leather version. This style fits great on me in a size 10M in the leather version, but the patent version feels a half a size too small and is extremely narrow and stiff. The style is great, but not consistent across materials. I would order this in 10W if it were in stock, because I love it.

It would be a real classic if it had a leather outsole, the rest of it sounds fantastic, I would order with a leather outsole.

This shoe is so cute! Unfortunately, it does not fit. It runs very narrow (narrower than boat shoes). Even 1/2 a size up is too narrow, which is disappointing. Crossing my fingers the Wide comes back in stock!

Beautiful shoes, but sadly they are too narrow. I tried to wear them for a few days to loosen them up, but they make my feet tingle from the sizing.

I own several pairs of Sperrys and always have worn a 10M, even in boots. These, however, were both too short and too tight. They are a gorgeous pair of shoes, and the styling is really sleek with a dressy silhouette, but too narrow, and there are currently no wide widths available. Sadly, not comfortable at all.

This shoe is adorable but I can't even get my foot in it! And I'm a 9.5/10 shoe size. I've tried everything short of oil but it's not a fit. Too bad. Was really looking forward to wearing this weekend.

I ordered 2 pairs of the same style in different colors. The tan pair fit perfectly and is very comfortable. The black pair in the same size was out of shape and slipped on my heel. It is ashame but I will think twice before buying again. Not worth the trouble to return. I gave them to a neighbor

Not as confortable as others. Good quality but doesnt feel as nice as other feom Same brand

A little disappointed when I actually received these. The leather is has a textured finish and while not necessarily very thin, the outer part feels very fragile (for lack of a better word). It's like it's not cow leather but a cheaper, thinner, leather. I seriously doubt they will last long without becoming marred. Online I thought the color was more of a "natural" leather or even saddle leather color, but they are so yellow I doubt I will have anything they'll look good with. They also have a strange smell. They don't smell like leather, and have a hint of menthol or something. They are very narrow, which for me is good. But not at the heel - so with every step they slide off and will probably cause blisters.

This is my second pair, this one is a bit wide and slip off when walking

Every time I wear these shoes the black dye rubs off on my feet.

Okay just flat not like the photo try them on inside