Customer Reviews Sperry Seaport Penny

I have worn these shoes for a few weeks. They are extremely comfortable. It did run a little small and I was promptly sent the correct size as requested upon receiving it initially. However, yesterday I noticed that the stitches are unraveling on the right shoe. Upon closer inspection, the stitches seem to have disintegrated at someplace and the entire side seems to be coming undone.

I typically wear a size 8.5, but purchased a 9 in Black. They are still too narrow and now too long. Unfortunately, the wide was sold out so I have to return them. Regarding the look of the shoe. The leather looks amazingly rich, but I am not a fan of the rubber sole. Would look better, in my opinion, if the sole was leather and the sole sides were black too for a monochromatic look.

This is my third pair of seaports. I sized up a 1/2 size in all three. The blush and navy fit great with a little breaking in. However, the brown is almost too small, tight and very narrow. So sizing is super inconsistent?!

Had to return. Needed a women's 13. Maybe next time?

The Seaport Penny Loafers are my favourite shoes! These are the shoes I wear almost exclusively, I even have a pair I wear in the house. They have fit me perfectly every time, never having to break them in, and even brand new, they feel like an old, comfortable pair of shoes. But when I got the tan ones recently, I put them on and could barely walk! It was as if they were a size too small, and the upper grated against the top of my feet. For some reason, the sides of the left shoe gaped (the right shoe didn't) and I could barely walk across the carpet in my bedroom, let alone wearing them for a whole day. What a huge disappointment, and I had to send them back right away. I would be reluctant to try another pair (I was hoping to get the navy ones in the near future) and I guess I'll have to just take very good care of the four pairs that I already have.

This would have been a a great shoe that got better with time I'm sure, but sadly it ran small and they don't make the shoe any larger than size 12. That being said, the return process couldn't have been easier.

I wear a size 9 in all shoes. I got these in a 9.5 wide and they are still to narrow. It's a tug of war to put my foot in the shoe.

This shoe is beautifully made, however, it was so tight I could t even get my foot into it. I am awaiting a size exchange.

Perfect style, material, colors and heel/sole. A classic loafer. Love it. Too bad it is way too wide. I am a medium width on the narrow side for most shoes. This is a wide shoe, as are all Sperry mediums. Why isn't there a narrow size offered? Returned reluctantly.

11M has always been my Sperry size but this style is too narrow and I had to return; they maybe could have stretched out but I wanted to keep the sleek look for work. I'll be trying a 12M and hoping it helps!

Beautiful patent leather shoe in navy - I so wanted these shoes to work but I couldn't get my foot into the 8.5M. I have 15 pairs of Sperry shoes, all in 8.5M, but these would not budge! Must be the patent leather. I sadly had to return them.

Love the look of this classic black leather loafer. The fit compared to the size is not the standard. I couldn't even get my foot inside this shoe. I normally wear a medium width. Even though I have a narrow heel - medium widths fit. Not this shoe. I tried it on with a very light weight sock. I'm ordering this to wear this winter so a sock is essential. I'm reordering in a half size bigger & in the wide width. I'll keep you posted.

I wanted to love this loafer (still live the look and quality), but it is too narrow and tight; and also makes my feet look big since I had to go up in size. I had to return. Wish that it is made normal - or wider - so that it can wear it. The style would have been perfect in office.

I did not like the look of the leather quality for price.

I love this shoe but have to return due to comfort. I would reorder in a wide, but the red doesn't seem to come that way. Too bad they are so narrow!

I have another pair of Sperry's in the exact same size and width, so I used that as the benchmark for ordering this pair. Unfortunately, these ones do not fit remotely the same. Beautiful design, but too narrow to fit my foot. Had to return.

I'm normally a 9 and so that is what I ordered. They were way too small when they arrived.

This loafer is an exquisite idea of how a loafer can double as a boat shoe. It's classic style and great snazz colors made it a favorite for me to order. The problem is in the heel quality. The sole has an entire "rubber like" non skid material. The heel has a very thin layer of that material on white clicker clack slippery plastic. If you wear your fav shoes like I do, that heel wears down to the plastic in about 4 months. Not a big fix when I brought it to Sperrys attention. But still maufactured the same way. Too bad since the style, comfort and colors are perfect.

These shoes are cute and look great! However, when you actually begin to move, problems arise. I have had these shoes for almost a year and they still dig into the back of my ankle whenever I walk. The quality of the leather is alright, but there is very little rubber on the heel of the shoe. The bottom started to peel off of my shoe within a few days and completely peeled off of the heel within a few months. It is not that I was walking a lot either, they are simply not made for anything than to look semi-nice. Not functional.

I have the shoes in pink, 7.5 W, very comfortable. I wanted to get them in brown or black, purchased brown 7.5 W, the length was right, but the width did not work, too tight. I have small bunions on both feet. Unfortunately had to send them back. Thank you Sperry for making my return so easy.