Customer Reviews Sperry Seaport Penny

Beautiful in pink, fits a bit narrow and small. Great quality, great for work and casual.

Color suggestions: Rose gold, charcoal, cordavon, navy, olive, dusty blue...

Just bought this loafer and it arrived very quickly. It is made very well, however seems to fit a bit snug. I am a 10m typically and rarely have to wear a size up or down. I'm going to keep the current size and wear them abit to stretch them out. The leather is so soft and supple, I'm betting that they will be a good overall shoe.

I just got mine in the mail and they seem too narrow! I do not have a wide foot and ordered my normal size 7 when I am sometimes a 6.5 and I could barely get my feet inside. I have the most average foot and never have issues buying shoes online. I see the W are out of stock so I cant even exchange them. The silver ones also have an odd smell. Debating if I am going to keep them.

I'm a true 8.5 size. This shoe is beautiful, but definitely not true to size. Great look, just can't fit in it. Returning it to get the next size up.

I am currently wearing these for the first time. I'm a solid 7.5-8 in every shoe I wear and the 8s are so tight on my feet. I bought the black ones too in the same size and they fit just fine and were even a little loose but the ivory ones don't fit right.

These shoes are very nice and would have kept them, too small, gave to daughter. RUN small, as I am a perfect 7 1/2 med

They need to make these shoes in wide size. Love my boat shoes only if they came in a 9w

Left shoe is larger than right:( I need to wear 2 no show socks on that foot

I own two pairs of these loafers (gray and tan) and thought the black would be an additional good choice. The reason for three stars is they are just as comfortable as my others however they turn my feet black from the dye used on the leather if I don't wear socks with them.

Nice looking shoe but unfortunately I returned them because they were too narrow. I suggest to go up a size for comfort. I have narrow feet size 8 with bunions, so......view this as a point of reference. However I definitely recommend these leather loafers since they're so well made.

Extremely tight in my foot. I have 2 other pair like this and they are beyond comfy.

I LOVE this shoe, in fact, I already have two pair in different colors. However, the right shoe was perfect, but the left shoe was too tight in the toe area and the stitching further up on the shoe irritated my foot. I wanted to exchange them for another pair but they had no more in my size, so I wound up returning them. Too bad because they are wonderful classic penny loafers!

I'm surprised no one has mentioned the soles of this shoe. I have several other loafers like this and they are amazing. This new style sounds clunky when I walk and it sounds like I'm not properly walking. I cannot get them to sound "normal." It's almost like I'm not bending my foot and just stomping. They felt AMAZING day one though. So comfortable. I just don't like they way they wear.

This shoe doesn't come in wide width. In your boat shoe I bought from you, and other manufacturers, if I go up a size, then the width of the shoe seems to fit my shoe. Example, 6 M is too narrow but 7 M is ok. Is this the case with this style?

This loafer runs narrow in the toe box area. I have two other pairs and they are the same. They need to be worn a few times before the leather stretches and they become comfortable

They fit too loose on my feet. I cannot wear them without socks. They fit in the toe but flop on my heel. I should have tried them on before buying them.

Very narrow shoe!! I want to Love the shoe, so much!!! I felt like Cinderella's step sister with the glass slipper. I have small, normal width feet, sized 6.5 shoe normally, can wear up to a 7 in boots with thick socks. I loved the look and feel of these tan Seaport Penny Exotic Leather shoes. The length was long enough, might have even been too long (measured next ro my foot from the bottom side of the sole). I was not ever able to slide my foot into the shoe. Used little thin no show socks. Even tried without socks. Feet NOT swollen. Tried in the morning, after swimming in a cold pool, tried in the afternoon. Tried the next day. So disappointed. Wanted to love the shoes. Made for extremely narrow feet. Finally gave up and mailed them back.

Great color, nice leather, however, stretches dramatically after first wearing!! Return department wonderful and efficient.