Customer Reviews KEEN Evofit One

So comfy. I cannot wear all Keens because the toebox a lot of times it’s not roomy enough. This toebox accommodate all my bunions and irregularities. Because of the elastic nature of the top I think you could be any width foot and it would conform. These are very comfy.

I have SO much trouble finding wide enough shoes for my bunions and various problems. These were comfy right out of the box and very flattering. I hope to order another pair. I am usually a 91/2 wide and the 9 1/2 fits perfectly. I will try more Keen brand.

Runs small. I had to return for a half size over my normal size, because my toes were bumping against the shoe toe. It might be the removable insole or the snug knit top that makes it run small. I’m hoping the knit will stretch out a little. But the shoe is cute, and there is no rubbing from straps, like on regular Keen sandals.

I tend to love Keens. They generally fit my foot very well. But the "sock" part of the Evofit One was quite tight and uncomfortable. And the side slits were badly placed for my foot...letting part of it bulge out and look odd.

waaaaaaay cuter in person!

Our family just returned from a trip to Bryce Canyon & Zion, where I sported these cute, comfy shoes. I wore them on our Narrows hike in Zion (the Narrows is a MUST-do, btw!), and they felt great! We crab-walked the river and hiked for 6 hours r/t (you choose how far to hike). I was so glad to be wearing these shoes. After grabbing a quick bite, we went on another hike—on land this time—and my Keens were shoe rock stars again! After that hike, it was a bonus that I could wade right into the river to cool off. Love these shoes!

This is my second pair of Evofit Keens. I love them. I have bunions and arthritis and have to select shoes carefully and these are perfect! They are comfortable with or without socks and they have become my current “go-to” shoe.

Keens are great shoes. Fit well, look great. Very comfortable walking and great in the bay as water shoes.

These were a hit right out of the box. Walked 6 miles on the Vegas strip first time out. Highly recommend these shoes and will definitely be looking for another pair.

Way too tight. I'm going to order one size up.

Awesome shoe!!! I have worn the Keen Whisper for a few years and love. I have flat feet and a bunion. Thought I would try the Evo... the removable footbed looked interesting. So glad I did!!! It is very comfortable the footbed is cushy and supportive with a nice arch. The sock like top around your ankle is very soft and there are no hard straps to rub or irritate. I highly recommend this shoe.

I love these. They do fit snug around the top part but usually it’s because as I put them on the lip rolled under making it tight. Once that’s resolved, they’re great! I can wear all day, right away, and my feet feel great

Very comfortable, hugs your foot. Lots of support. Perfect walking shoe for Disney World. I di d order 1/2 size larger than usual. I like room in the toe box. Excellent customer service.

I have a large, wide foot, am flat-footed, and have a high in-step. Keens have always been a go-to because of the support and comfort they offer my feet, which are difficult to fit. I’ve owned a lot of Keens. After two weeks and nearly two decades of Keens, I’m comfortable saying the Evofit is my favorite Keen. I love that it fits like a sock without being constricting. I’m active and outdoors a lot. This works for walking, hiking, playing at the beach or the park, or whatever the day brings. I’ve always loved that Keens do well with water - that’s something I think the Evofit does even better because of the fit. Really love this shoe.

These are amazingly comfortable shoes which will be my go-to's for summer bike rides to concerts and kayaking on the reservoir. The sole is fairly rigid with a slight give for the toes. It is not built for rugged hiking, but has a grippy sole that should work for most everyday putzing about. As always with Keens, order a half size up. I'm a solid 39 which can sometimes be an 8 or 8.5. The 8.5 is marked as the Keen 39.

Was looking forward to these for use walking in the water, kayaking, and boating. I need excellent arch support and prefer to be able to insert my custom orthotics, when not in the water. However, I usually weae an 11, and my toes were right at the top of these in size 11. Thus, I am out of options, as 11 is the largest women's size available, and am returning these.

I was very excited to find a Keen sandal with a removable foot bed. Three pieces of sturdy velcro hold the Keen insoles in place. They are somewhat difficult to remove, but not impossible. These are the sturdiest removable insoles I've ever seen in a Keen shoe, but I still replaced them with my own orthotics, which fit perfectly inside the sandal. The shoes were stiff at first and a little hard to put on, but after a few wearings, they go on and off much easier. A note on size: I had to return my usual Keen 8 for an 8.5, which feels much roomier for my toes. I'm giving the Keen Evofit One 4 stars for now, because I've still not worn them out of doors, and I'm not sure how well the new synthetic materials will wear over time.

These are shorter than previous Keens, but I read earlier reviews so I ordered the correct length. I love the lightweight structure, the arch support and the comfort, but the stretchy part around the ankle is just too tight. Changing sizes won't make a difference. If you have skinny ankles, you'll be fine.

I really wanted these shoes to work because they are soooo comfortable. However, the top (the hole your foot goes in to put the shoe on) is way too tight. It is a stretchy, sock like material, but it was already leaving a dent in my foot/ankle just in the short time I tried them on (like wearing socks that are too tight in the top band). I even ordered another pair a full size larger than the already sized up ones I first ordered and they were also too tight. I love the sole/footbed though. Keen needs to use this sole on all their shoes!

This is a great shoe, but terrible as a water shoe. I bought these to use at the lake (kayaking and paddle boarding) and in the water. The problem is that they have a removable insole and sand and grime get underneath the insole. The shoes also developed a terrible smell since getting wet. I love how comfortable they are, but hate that they don’t work as well as my old keens for water activities.

In late May I purchased a pair of these in black. Having read the reviews, I ordered a half size up. They were perfect, I thought, and fit my narrow-ish foot just right. I loved them; they're comfortable and I think they're also good looking. I wear them in "city" conditions, rather than for hiking like I do my Keen Newports. So at the end of July I ordered another pair, in grape. I haven't opened that second pair up yet, but I think I'm going to send them back. Why? Because just after I received them I noticed that the heel cup of the anatomical footbed on my black Evofits had been seriously disintegrating. Photos attached. The right shoe was worse, but the left one has the problem too. It's been getting worse, and I anticipate that the footbed will disintegrate within another couple of months. That's unacceptable for a two-month old pair of shoes worn only in very tame conditions. Very disappointing. I was in love with these shoes, and I would have loved to have the grape too, but I can't justify the purchase given their very short life.

Great shoes!

These are very comfortable and great for more stable "cool foot" summer wear. I need shoes with ankle and foot support so I can't wear flip flops or most sandals. These are great for everyday use and I actually use them for sailboat racing as well since they have a good sole, but won't hold water if they get wet. As with any shoe you wear barefoot, they will start to smell if they are constantly wet or don't get washed semi-regularly with everyday "dry" use. The look and style is also nice since they cover your toes for a more athletic feel. I have had them for a while and they've lasted without much wear and tear so I'd say they are durable and high quality. I would definitely buy them again (when these eventually need to be replaced) and would recommend them to others.

These are perfect water shoes. We spend a lot of time at the lake and the river and these are comfortable, supportive and grippy on slippery rocks.

I really like this shoe, reminiscent of my beloved Coronado and McKenzie as for how they feel on my feet. The color wouldn’t have been my first choice but the black wasn’t in my budget just now. I sure miss my Coronado’s though, my favorite shoe ever!