Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Gigi

These shoes are really good looking and the pony hair is good quality. But the strap that goes between your toes is much wider than other thongs so it presses against your toes. It is rough fabric so I know it would kill my feet. I returned them.

Bought this sandal as I have a wide foot and most sandals don't accommodate. The base of the shoe at the ball and toe of the foot is cut to fit someone with a pointy toed foot, versus a flat across toed foot. Therefore, I felt my toes were falling off the edge of this shoe. Better than another pair that I had tried and returned. Also, the shoe was a little loosey goosey even when I used the last hole on the ankle strap.

Cute, but the angle of the toe-bed makes my normal-width feet hang over the outside of the footbed. These are going back. Thank goodness for Zappos famous easy returns.

I ordered half a size up and ordered the wide, and they were still too narrow and my big toe hung off the shoe…so while they are a cute shoe, they are not cute on my feet. If you have thin narrow feet, these will work for you. If you have wide feet, don’t bother, because even the “wide” shoe is ridiculously narrow.

Too big and too flat for my tired feet..

Very cute, but very very narrow! I ordered my normal size 13 and it was both to small and to narrow

I have several pairs of Gigi sandals in all different colors in the same size I ordered here. On this pair, the straps were extremely tight and not flexible. I am returning.

This style has an odd fit. No matter what size I order, my toes hang off the front of the footbed. I can't find any size to fit me properly, so I'm returning all.

This shoe was super cute but expensive for what it is...a non-supportive cute shoe. I am mostly returning it because the color I selected camo looked like beige suede with coffee or mud spilled on it- the leather surfaces are too small to see the camo pattern.

The shoes are very narrow compared to other regular width sandals. Returning them due to that fact. My foot is over the edge slightly on the sides. Cute sandals if you have a very very narrow foot. Foot bed is cushioned nicely.

The gold color and snake pattern is pretty, but I had to return these. The size was right, but when I walked my toes got pushed forward and over the front. I wear many other thong style sandals that do not do this.

So disappointed! Such a classic sandal, that I would have kept in a heartbeat, but the sole is way too narrow...and I am a medium width. The top of the sole angles down...if your toe line has a distinct slope down, you are good. If your toes is more level across, there not enough width. The sole of the sandal is narrow from mid sole on up.

I love these sandals. I am a true 7 in pretty much all shoes and sandals, including Sam Edelman but these definitely run 1/2 size small. The 7 1/2 fits perfectly. I bought the black and gold. The leather is supple and comfortable but I did NOT like the color of the gold ones. They were WAY too shiny and tacky for me. I prefer a more muted, low key, sophisticated finish. If you want a god sandal that's more shiny and blingy these are for you!

Beautiful sandal but the footbed is very slippery. Sadly I'm returning these before I even attempt to walk in public in them. I'm sure it wouldn't be pretty.

I love the look of these sandals and I guess I should be happy that they lasted me two seasons, but I'm not. At this price, I think they should last a lot longer. As soon as I received them, I was worried about the flimsy piece of elastic that connects the buckle to the strap. It made the sandals feel floppy, and sure enough, the elastic broke. These days, it's difficult to find someone who can repair shoes so I guess I'm going to call it a loss and pitch them. Very disappointed. I found someone who makes sandals by hand on Etsy (not China, like these) and although I haven't received them yet, they look a hell of a lot sturdier than the Sam Edelman sandals and they're just as attractive. Oh, and they're cheaper.

I love the style of these sandals but if you want to wear for extended periods of times it's not good. They are not comfortable, especially if you have a arch. And the strap is very hard to do at first.

Very cute sandal. I received constant compliments about them every time I wore them. However, after having them only 1 summer they broke! I normally get a few summer wears out of my sandals and the fact that I paid twice as much for these, I really expected more. So if you want to get sandals for 'delicate' use these will probably work for you. But if you are looking for a sandals you can wear to work and out and about you should probably keep shopping.

Love the color options available in this trendy sandal but the fit didn't work for me. Typically an 8-8.5, I ordered an 8.5 and my last 3 toes hung over the edge just enough to need a 9. But I won't be ordering a 9. The sole of this sandal is cut for those who have the "model" foot. With the big toe the longest and the rest tapering down like stairs. However, my second toe is the longest which left for too much extra sole exposed above my big toe. They just looked weird to me. I'm not marking them as a "narrow" because I didn't feel like the shoe overall was narrow. Just a very tapered toe cut design.

I love the look of these. They really are excellent. Unforunately, the strap broke the third time I wore them. Exchanging and hoping that the next pair are better quality.

These shoes are comfortable but my feet keeps on sliding forward. I just wished the toe strap was made maybe a 1/4 to 1/2 back so my toes doesn't keep on touching the ground. Had to send it back.

Such a CUTE shoe unfortunately it is very ill fitted and uncomfortable. The shape of the sole does not contour to the average foot. These sandals run extremely narrow yet the strap between the toes is wider than it should be. I wear a size 7 and I had to order an 8 in this sandal. There's absolutely no arch support and by the end of day my foot did not feel very comfortable. If you're wearing this sandal to church or other short outings, then it should be fine. But this is NOT the shoe that you wear for lots of walking or shopping.

Very cute but way too narrow. I think I have average width feet and my toes were hanging off the sides!

After reading all the positive reviews I was really looking forward to receiving these. I normally wear an 8 or 8.5 and the length of the 8.5 was perfect. However, they were SO narrow that my feet were hanging all the way off on both sides. I definitely don't have wide feet by any means! I really wish they worked because the leopard and snakeskin combination is so cute.

I wanted these to fit so badly. They are adorable and I think they are perfect for the summer. But unfortunately, my foot hangs off the side (and I do not have wide feet), so they are going back.

These sandals are so cute and the best colors I've seen this season. Plus, they seemed to have a little more padding than many of the strappy, flat sandals. However, they run extremely small. I sometimes wear 7 1/2 and sometimes an 8. I first ordered these in size 8 and they were too small. I loved them so returned to get an 8 1/2 and ordered in five colors. I have never bought an 8 1/2 in my life and these shoes still didn't fit. They are extremely narrow and my toes hung over the edge even though the length verged on too long to wear. I have several pairs of Sam Edelman shoes and always need a size 8 in this brand, but have never had a problem with the width. If you have narrow feet, go for it. These are really cute sandals.