Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Rodney

The shoe wore easily and within one month there were holes in the heel.

Beautiful shoe! I really wanted it to work but it just doesn't fit my foot well. Not enough coverage across the top by my toes. I am not into any toe cleavage!  Also my feet are on the wider side of average, I don't buy wide shoes but these shoes were not very flattering for a foot on the wide side. You hang out the side a little. I thought that may happen but wanted to try them anyway. The detail on the back is very nice! It really shines!

The front didn’t fit well; I was spilling out of even the wide. Ultra point made my foot look extra long — it was unflattering. Disappointed :(

i love the style but seems to me they run a whole size larger. I am a 6.5 and even the 6 slips out. 5.5 out of stock...

The fit was snug and my toes showed at the toe. But I was most unhappy about how they were shipped. They were not in an SE box but in a large box and were not adequately wrapped. One of the shoes was stuck inside the toe of the other shoe. I have never had a zappos order arrive that way. The shoes must have been a prior return without packaging but that shouldn't have prevented good wrapping to protect the shoes. I have shown how the shoes were received and the fact there was only 1 piece of wrapping paper.

I find that Sam Edelman flats run big. These are also too large (in length) but run very narrow. The point of the shoe is pretty long too which I found unattractive. Even if these did fit, they seem like they would be uncomfortable.

I really wanted to love these shoes because it's a great style in a size 4. I have extremely small feet (size 2.5 kids W), but have had good luck with the Sam Edelman Size 4 heels. These slipped off my feet, probably because they are flats vs. heels. I still would have tried to make them work with an insert but I'm returning them because they have also been incredible painful breaking in after a week. I had cuts and blisters on both the front and back of my feet where the edging of shoe meets. Maybe it's due to being the wrong size, but in addition to this, the insert came unglued after a few days. Overall returning. Maybe better luck for someone else, but these did not stand up/were not comfortable for me.

These shoes were extremely uncomfortable. I wore once for a few hours and ended up with large blisters!

My usual size 6, but it was way to big. I could not even walk in them, they just flopped around on my foot. I ordered a half size down 5.5 and they were way too small. They pinched my toes and heel. Had to return both pair, which was a real shame because they are so cute.

Ordered two pairs of these. First pair wasn’t comfortable and the leopard pattern wasn’t what I was expecting. Too brown. Ordered a second pair hoping it would work out, but they were way too big and I didn’t like the pattern in person, either. Sadly, back these go.

These run very large. I am a 9.5 and ordered a 9.5 but these were slipping off my feet with a good 3/4 to spare on the back of my heel. I just ordered a 9 and hope they fit. Otherwise I will order a 8.5? Definitely order a size down.

It's a beautiful shoe, but it pinched when I was wearing it around the house. I also anticipated the back of the shoe rubbing my heels raw. These felt very narrow. I seem to have this problem with Sam Edelman shoes. Maybe my feet are wide or their shoes are narrow? Maybe both?

These are very cute shoes but hit just where I have a bunion, so I could barely keep them on for a minute. I bought my normal size and did not feel it was large at all. In fact if anything, it was tight everywhere. Sadly must return.

Poor value for the price. Didn’t feel like it would stay on your foot and the heal was so thin, it wouldn’t last a long walk.

I placed 3 different orders of three different sizes & still haven’t gotten the right size so I’m giving up! The style is right on but the sizing is definitely off! Im disappointed but sick of dealing with returns!

Love thus shoe but they are terribly uncomfortable. Returned

I bought these cute shoes in both the black suede and navy floral, so I was really disappointed when they didn't look good on my feet. The toe box is cut very low, so my toes were all pretty visible - it didn't look as nice as I'd like. My toes also are not especially long. They are cute, but disappointing

I really wanted to like this shoe. Very cute, but they run at least 1 size too large. Also the toe area is so short, that you have five toes of cleavage.

I like the style, but they shredded my heels. They're just a bit too long and the heel slipped all day which rubbed the skin off my heels. It was such a subtle bit too large that I didn't catch it before I wore these to work. Now I'm stuck with shoes that I cannot wear and I cannot exchange. ??

I love the style and color of these shoes when they're NOT on my feet, but once on, it's ALL toe cleavage. I'm OK with a little toe cleavage, but with these shoes, all my toes are visible. Needs a couple inches or more coverage. I bought the W width and the toe box was still too narrow, but the length fit my normal size well. They're going back :(