Customer Reviews Dr. Scholl's Work Harrington II

So far they haven't fallen apart like the last pair did (side panels almost immediately began to decay and they were not made of leather - the leather portions wore very well).

The top of the heel is a little too low and even when tied tight, my heel pops out of the shoe and then crushes the shoe heel top as my foot tries to settle back in. I do not like the textured Harrington toes, but that is the only style Dr. Scholl's offers. The length/width size of the shoe itself was accurate.

Was a great shoe in the beginning. Heel keeps separating after about a month.

While I've only had the shoes for a few weeks, they seem to have a reasonably durable leather that still manages to be flexible; I'm a handyman and am constantly moving, walking and kneeling and need shoes that move with me without binding across my instep. They definitely have a very good no-slip sole. However, the insoles that came with them aren't very good. They didn't have enough cushion for my feet. However, once I bought a good set of insoles (from a different manufacturer), my feet are quite comfortable and happy.

Shoe fits well and is comfortable. Soles need to be thicker and more dense if you are on concrete all day true to size

These are not as wide as they used to be. Looks like someone has cut down on materials. The shape of the sole is very different from previous pairs.

Bottom layer of heel came unglued after 2 days of use. Glued it back in place and it has held up for now. Like the look and feel but did not expect to have to make repairs to 2 day old shoes.

I had to go down a size and it still feels slightly too big. I should have just gone for the normal fit instead of the wide too, despite having wider feet. This is the second size I've tried ordering. I'm keeping them just because it leaves room for thick socks in the winter time. It's honestly a big disappointment though. I was expecting more cushion and a little more arch support from this brand. My feet took a couple days to break in the shoes. Not to mention they are kind of heavy, which I was not expecting. Walking around all day felt a little more tiring.

We shall see how long the lining holds up. Prefer zero-drop shoes. Not enough arch support.

The shoe laces should not last longer than the soles. These shoes are very comfortable and the uppers are attractive, sturdy and durable. I won't buy again because the soles are wearing away so quickly.

My dad bought these some months back, an the insides, soles are all still good...but the leather is peeling off. Is there a warranty on that for him...Im attaching pictures to show the good n bad.

Consider making a smaller size. In your women selection limited and some women like buying the men's shoes but they are to big.

I have the same pair of these in black and ordered the exact same size and yet these are noticeably larger...at least a half size. The return says you can send back unworn but I needed them for the weekend so I just bought some thicker socks and went with it. I never order shows online because I know you have to try them on but I thought I was safe because I have the same pair in a different color. Wrong. Ugh! My fault but very disappointed

Not as comfortable as my Scholl's Warner 2537363, leather upper. The toe is too thick with no stitching to protect the shoe leather. I would by another pair of the ones I already have, but I cannot find this particular shoe.

I reordered this because my son said these helped his plantar fasciitis with the gel insert. These don't have the gel, not as comfy as first pair.

I have purchased these for about the last 10 years, but these are being made cheaper every time I purchase them. The soles were better in the past & now the outer surface looks cheaper. The shoes are comfortable, but I will see how long these last this time. I may need to start looking for something else.

I have purchased these for about the last 10 years, but these are being made cheaper every time I purchase them. The soles were better in the past & now the outer surface looks cheaper. The shoes are comfortable, but I will see how long these last this time. I may need to start looking for something else.

These shoes are over all very good, but marred by several factors out of the box. The chief problem is they are 'wide,' but not as wide as my feet. The second problem: parts of the sole came off out of the box; it has an outermost layer which lost portions on the heal and at the edges. This occurred on both shoes. The last problem was a long break-in period. I had to wear moleskin on my left achilles tendon and right little toe.

Have been wearing these for several years and could not find in the store anymore. Was happy to see on line. Was nervous because the price is exactly the same now as it was a few years ago, which usually means the quality/materials suffer. They pinch at the toes - even though I got wide. Can't comment yet abut quality since I've only been wearing them around the house for a few days - but the "wide" width is definitely not for American feet!

I work in a meat room where slip resistance is very important. I've use quite a few pair of the TX model, and they are much better when it comes to not sliding all over. Secondly, it is much easier to clean the soles of the TX models with a stiff brush. The soles of the Harrington II's trap little pieces of meat and I have to dig them out with an old nail file. If I don't do this, the shoes will eventually smell horrible. These shoes are comfortable, but they are not convenient. Too bad, I liked the older model much better.

I bought these shoes about two weeks ago and the soles are already falling apart. I will be going and asking for my money back and trying a different shoe. It's too bad because these shoes are super comfortable which I need since I spend my day on my feet.

The soles started separating from the show in less than a month after purchase