Customer Reviews Lucky Brand Cahill

Heel slips runs large

I ordered these in my usual 7.5 and they were very snug - too snug to work with no-show socks even. The upper is a soft and flexible leather, but is very thin. They won't keep you warm if you're planning to wear these in cold weather, and they feel like they would wear out quickly. I couldn't justify the price for these so am returning.

I like the simplicity of the style but I don't like how the material looks and feels. It isnt worth the price in my opinion. I usually wear a 9 and it fit like a glove. I would suggest getting 1/2 a size bigger if you want to wear no-show socks or add inserts for a little more cushioning.

These are so cute but feel 1/2 size too big. I'm returning in hopes the 7.5 fits better. I very rarely fit in anything less than an 8 so fingers crossed. I've been looking for a shoe this style and this has been the most affordable option that I actually like.

Shoe looks great, it’s fairly comfortable but it slides off the foot too easily. Very little support.

I really wanted to love these shoes. The style is really cool in person. I was looking for a casual/dressy loafer and this one really fitted what I was looking for. BUT the back can be worn up or under the heel (like a slipper) and because of this, it felt like it was not holding my foot in the back at all. I had the impression that I was going to lose the shoes as I was walking. I'm usually between the 7 and 7.5. I tried it in 7 and it was a little tight in the front.

Lucky Brand Cahill size 11 are too big for my 10.5 feet, but as usual no half sizes over 9.5! Need more styles in 10.5 overall, please. These have no arch support, like walking on a piece of plywood. Leather is very thin and flimsy, no structure or support. Cute for some, but not what I am looking for.

I don't know how to rate these. They're super cute, and I wish they'd worked out, but the 7.5's (my normal size) were far too small, and the 8's I ordered to replace them were laughably large. So do they run small or large?! Who knows! Or maybe you'll get lucky and they'll work for you.

I really wanted to like these shoes. The back part that allows you to wear as a loafer or slip on was just too flimsy and the shoe would not stay on my foot properly.

I so badly wanted to love these. The style is great. I really liked the way they looked. And the leather is very soft and comfortable. The only issue is that the leather is so thin/flimsy/flexible that on the back of the heels it slips up and down or somehow collapses with each step. There is no way I would have been able to wear these out of my house. With each step I had to clench my foot muscle to try to keep them from slipping, but even that wasn't always effective. It's not a sizing issue, as the shoe fit just fine, and sizing down wouldn't have fixed it. I was one of the people who read the reviews saying these things and decided to take a chance because I loved the look of the shoe. I guess I should have believed the other reviewers.

Loved the shoe, but had to return because the back of the shoe is so flimsy that it folds down around my foot.

This was a strange fit. The length and width in the toe was spot on, but my heal slipped which makes them unwearable, and a smaller size won't work. The slipping could be because of the soft leather, not a lot of structure in the back. Bummed I'll have to return and pick a new loafer.

Loved the look in the picture, but the heel of the shoe is nothing more than leather, no binding or any kind of support to make it hold its shape. Too bad its got to go back -

I absolutely loved the shoes and they are made well, however, they fit loose and are so very soft.

This shoe has a nice soft leather at a quality you would you expect in this price range. I purchased the indigo and the bijou. The indigo is light, it is not what I expected for this color. I think of indigo as being a deep, vibrant navy. This is a medium blue that is a pretty color. You will like the color if you are not expecting a dark blue. The bijou is a nice beige-ish tan-ish color. In certain lights it has just a hint of pink. The shoe is designed to be convertible and worn as either a mule or a smoking slipper style loafer. The leather at the heel is appropriately soft enough to flatten inward and be comfortable for wearing as a mule. Unfortunately it is far too soft to maintain its structure for wearing as a loader. If you purchase the shoe a size down or add nonslip pads to the back heel they may work out as loafers. For the price, I will be returning them and shopping around for another convertible loafer/mule.

The back of the heel has no structure, and the leather is very soft. As soon as I tried them on and took a few steps the leather began to scrunch down under my heel.

Very soft leather and comfy, but sadly, the back slipped. Returned.

I actually own these flats in brown leather already and was looking for a pair of black flats to wear to work. I loved the brown ones so much that I ordered these and I thought they were awesome until the second day I wore them, on Monday. They are tearing apart on the inside. I wore them at work, in an office setting, it's not like I was sprinting in them for eight hours, and they are already ripping apart on the inside, causing my toes to blister on the top and generally being uncomfortable. If I wasn't at work, I'd take a picture and post it, but they're sitting next to my trash can at home.

The heel has absolutely no support and flops off within 2 steps. It's not the fit -- everything about the shoe fits fine until I step forward. These shoes are not wearable.