Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Waterproof XC4® Stanton Panel Toe Slip-On

Just received them yesterday, and was a bit concerned they were tight when I put them on... then I read the little card that said there was a removable footbed that changes the width to a bit wider (read the card....right!) .... took it out, absolutely perfect.

My husband had an older version of these shoes that I bought him about 2.5 years ago. He totally abuses his shoes by walking through rain, snow, slush, and other central Ohio weather conditions. The old pair held up so nicely and were so comfortable that he asked me to order him another pair. These look great with his dress pants or with dark denim. Hopefully this new pair will last a couple of winters, and then I will buy him another pair. Great shoes!

This shoe was billed as "dual width", i.e. removing the insole would switch it from a medium width to wide. I don't t typically need a wide but the last pair was narrow so I decided to buy again thinking I could just remove the insole if needed. I found the bed of the shoe without the insole was still surprisingly smooth and finished but I was left without sufficient cushioning. The inside of the shoe looks good with the insole removed but it lost a key function ... cushioning. The" dual width" is useful if you have an occasional issue with foot swelling during a long flight, but it is not an ongoing solution to a shoe that runs too narrow.

Great shoes. This is my second pair of J&M shoes for work. Both are slip on and waterproof and the are great. These live up to what I expected and are well worth the money.

Great quality shoe, perfect fit for those with a wide foot.

These are a little tight out of the box, but they break in quick. They are definitely water proof. I'm a big fan of J&M. A quality shoe for sure

Super helpful that I can gauge my size based on my previous purchase of this same brand.

My husband loves this shoe. He wore out his older pair from a few years ago of this same style, and this has been a great upgrade. He says they are very comfortable, and I can say they look great dressed up with a suit and even dressed down with khakis and jeans. We highly recommend

This shoe is nice, but felt really tight. hard to get on without a shoehorn

relatively narrow, even for an extra wide. had to return

Purchased these 0.5 size smaller than normal and they fit perfectly. In the beginning I take the second insole out and once the leather stretches a bit, I put the second insole back in and they stay snug. Truly waterproof and extremely comfortable

J&M is my husband's favorite brand. He usually wears a 13W, but in J&M dress shoes the 12 is a better fit -- they're a little snug at first, but the leather molds to your foot quickly. Quality shoes, very professional looking, and comfortable right out of the box.