Customer Reviews Sofft Selby

These are some good, good shoes. I tried them on along with some more expensive boots, and these were way more comfortable and looked as good as the pricier options. I got them the day before we left for a trip where I knew we were going to spend two days on our feet literally all day, plus walking through airports, etc., so I really needed them to be comfortable immediately, and they were. Snug, comfy, stylish...just all around great.

LOVE this shoe - the fit, the style, everything! Super comfortable. My only complaint (and it's a bit of a non-complaint) is that they are not as red as they look in the picture. But the color is gorgeous. Anyway, I love them so much that I also bought them in blue....

Whiskey Athens color is my second pair I love these boots so much. I also have them in Olive. I have foot/toe issues and can't wear most shoes. I have resorted to buying mainly comfort shoes the last few years. These boots are the most comfortable I own and my toes are happy campers. I wear them with skirts, jeans, etc. dressed up or down. Whiskey Athens I have in a 6.5, the Olive in a 7.0. I normally wear a true 7, these run slightly long. I like the 7 because I can wear thicker socks.

This is my second pair of Sofft Selby boots. I bought this pair after wearing my black ones for 2 days and realizing I needed a pair in brown too! I wear both pairs most of the winter. They keep my feet warm and dry. They do run a little bit larger than normal - just enough to wear thicker socks which is exactly what I wanted.

Amazingly comfortable right out of the box! I am on my feet for 8+ hours a day at work, and my feet stayed happy in these all day without any breaking in needed. As one prone to plantar fasciitis, I was pleasantly surprised with the arch support of this shoe as well. I want more in all the colors!

Love these. Fit well right out of the box and no blistering! A tad snug across the top of foot but just feels like a secure fit, not tight.

I wear a size 10 and have what I think are normal width feet. The first two times I wore these with no socks because the thin socks I wear with my loafers made them too tight on the sides of my feet. I had to find a pair of dress socks that were almost like stockings. They have been broken in a little more and now I have no issues with them feeling tight. I also have plantar fasciitis and did not have any problems with the arch. Very comfortable, after being worn four times all day at work.

bought these for my 18 year old daughter for Christmas, she loves chelsea boots, says these are so comfortable and stylish

Bought these in both black and brown. Love these boots, so comfortable to wear and easy on and off.

I have a terrible time wearing anything but Danskos. However, these boots are very comfortable! They are cushioned, and broken-in right out of the box! Olive suede are especially soft. I would love more arch support, though. They run a little big, which gives me room for half-insole arch support. I have them in Olive, black, and red Aristo. The Whiskey Atlas were a much fuller tan than pictured

I purchased these boots for my mom, and she has told me that these are the most comfortable boots that she owns. They fit her true to size and look great as well with her outfits!

Love these booties. They are as soft as butter. No need to break them in. I love the various colors. I just order my second pair.

They are super comfy. And go well with skinny jeans of flare jeans. They are the all around type of shoe with a good comfort. They started to hurt my feet only after wearing them 12 hours straight on my feet the whole time.

This boot was crazy comfortable right out of the box and that is a very, very rare thing for me! Quality is very nice and exceeds my expectation for it especially give the price at under $80. Width was medium to ever so slightly wider of medium and that is perfect for my feet. I couldn't be happier!

This boot is stylish and VERY comfortable. There is a distressing on the toe which adds a bit of edge. I love the wood heal and the height is perfect for walking a lot. The inside has SUCH comfort you can wear all day. The shoe hits just at the ankle, so you can show them off.

These boots went on sale and I snatched them up. I'm glad I did. They are a very smart-looking boot with lots of style and the feel fantastic! I have bunions and I have no discomfort in toe box area. I like the low heel and the comfortable foot bed. It's the perfect boot for me.

I could not be happier with these boots! Not only are they super stylish, but the cushioning in the insole is incredible! The leather used for the boot is also soft and supple. I think these are probably one of the best boots I will own and may have to get another pair!

Nice rounded toe, reasonably wide, comfortable heel. There's no zippper but also no problem slipping on. Great boot for the price.

Fantastic. boots! Comfortable and stylish, I'm delighted to have these.

Rugged, comfortable and stylish. They are just as sold, very comfortable and can walk all day with great support and comfortable.

Love this bootie!! Looks cute with jeans and dresses!!

I've been wearing my pair of Sofft Selby boots for about a week now, and I love them!! The Whiskey Athens are much a much lighter shade than pictured, but still very smart. (I love the "burnt toe" style.) They're a little bit too large and my foot "lifts" a little bit out of the shoe when I walk, but I don't really know if that's fixable while stile maintaining the ease of putting it on/taking it off. I don't have a lot of experience with high heeled shoes, but I barely felt this "heel" at all, if anyone is worried about that. Arch support is pretty good! And the bed is just So. Comfortable. The boot isn't very warm though, so they won't be a good stand in for thick socks in the cold weather. The only real complaint I have is that the shaft chafes a little bit at the top. For a day or two I didn't wear these boots with tall socks, and no there's a nice ring around my leg from where the edge of the boots scraped me repeatedly. I'm hoping that over the next few days/weeks I break that in, because I'd rather not be trapped wearing tights for the next forever. I definitely recommend these!!

Love these boots. They felt great right out of the box. Wore them for the first time all day.

I ordered these originally in a 7.5 (though I normally wear an 8) due to reading the reviews that suggested one size down. I would NOT recommend this. I had to return and exchange for my normal size 8. Now, they fit perfectly, and I really do love the blue color. Very cute booties! I would go with your normal size on these, though. They fit snugly.

Bought these for a trip that entailed a lot of walking. These were extremely comfortable and I walked for a few days in these with no problems. I love these shoes and the color and would definitely buy again.