Customer Reviews Clarks Janey Mae

Ordered these in blacknubuck in a 6 and found them just a bit too short in length. Exchanged them today for a 6.5 in the navy suede since the nubuck was not available in the 6.5/ the toe box is wide but still cute and helps with my Morton's Neuroma in my toes! these are still "sensible" but stylish.

Bought these hoping I could wear them to work, I'm on my feet all day, but they were not as comfy as I expected them to be. This is my first attempt at Clark's. Really lovely shoe otherwise! Well made and high quality leather. If my closet wasn't already filled with cute casual shoes for being out and about, then I would consider keeping these.

Very cute and well made, but run at least a size smaller than most Clarks and minimal arch support.

I own an a 6 year old pair of clarks like these. The new version is not made nearly as well as the old and not as comfortable. All in all its an ok shoe. Love the looks not much for comfort

These are just what I was looking for, a casual brown leather show. Unfortunately, they felt too narrow and I had to return.

I thought these were cute but I couldn't get my foot in them even though I ordered a half size up. Didn't work for me.

After I ordered these I read the reviews and realized about over half the reviews said they ran small so called right away to order a larger size but they told me it was too late and they would send out a larger pair after I receive my original pair and determine they are too small. I received them today and they really weren't kidding....these run small!! ... I just had to look at them and I knew that they were small. After trying them on I am ordering a size 10 (which I never wear) as the 9 fit me like I tried on an 8. They feel like they are super comfy if they were bigger... looking forward to getting a correct fit.

These shoes Definitely run very small (by 1/2-1 size). If you like Clark's for their wonderful support, these aren't for you. Love the style and material but they have no arch support whatever. Returning them.

These are really cute shoes but the tongue digs into the top of each foot, so sadly I'll be returning and looking for other chukka styles.

Funky shoe that just didn’t work. They were a little short length wise and even if that wasn’t an issue I just wasn’t sure what I’d wear them with so back they went. I have a narrow bony fit and the width was fine.

Wanted these to work as a comfortable travel shoe. Unfortunately, I found them too stiff and uncomfortable. They have potential, and I like the quirky, hand-sewn look. But the uppers were stiff and the upper rim of the shoe felt kind of hard when it may contact with my flexed foot and ankle. Not much arch support and definitely run a half size small.

These shoes ended up looking like clown shoes - way too big in the front area. They looked unusual in the picture, but I didn't get the sense the front of the shoe was so big compared to the rest of the foot.

Super cute but a little short in the heel--does not come up far enough or want to stay on, even when laced tight. Wish Clarks would make more of its shoes in wide! Only a very thin sock would work for me.

I had high hopes for this shoe because I love Clarks. The shoe ran very small, I ordered a full size up. Unfortunately, there is very little support and the wide toe box was very unflattering.

I really liked the look of them, but can't really speak to how they fit - they were too small. I thought I'd checked, and didn't see reviews where folks needed to order larger sizes, but... I returned them and tried to order a larger size, but they were out of stock. STILL waiting for notification that the larger size is available.

I have 3 pairs of Clarks in my closet ALL size 9.5. These felt so tight and something about the cut of the shoes forced my big toe to the middle of the toe box. Another issue is that the insole is not removable and I wear orthotic inserts. They are cut and look very servicible for everyday wear so I will try a larger size.

This shoe should have been more comfortable than it was, given the shape. I am a true 10.5 on the left and a 10 on the right. I ordered up to an 11M. I only had to try on the left to know these were going back. Although I purchased these for the wide toe box construction (I have a German heritage wide toe box foot and regular width) my toes were quite smashed together and the big toe was hitting the front of the shoe. Looking at the sole of the foot I see now that the it is quite narrow, and not at all in alignment with the top generous construction which I purchased it for. Additionally, I noticed immediately that the shoe caused extreme pronation. So even if the shoe had fit my foot better it would have caused issues down the line with my hip and knees. It is a comfy looking shoe and cute enough for that style but not at all comfortable.

I returned these shoes because they were too small in my normal size. While I like the look of this shoe, I didn’t re-order in a larger size because the inside of the shoe seems unfinished with no lining.

These were a little tight. The 2nd time I wore them the stitching in the heel of the left shoe came undone. Usually Clarks are good quality shoes and these were not an example of that. They also run narrow. I'll stay away from this kind of style from now on.

I have to exchange these. I bought a 7. They feel like a size 5 or 6. Can't even get my foot in them to see if there's any arch support. Ok, I took off my thin sock, and got my foot in. Can confirm there isn't much arch support. Also, the back of the shoe slips off the heal a little. It's too short there or it could be because the heal piece is straight up and down instead of curved a little which would have hugged the heel. So sad. I love the look of these. And I love the toe area, shape and feel otherwise. Trying to decide if I should try an 8 or not. Currently on hold with zappos for second time. Can't exchange for some reason online.

This shoes were so stiff that I could not walk.

I am SO disappointed! I have another pair of these that are several years old and they are my favorite!!! These are too short! I wear a large shoe size and never even think about a shoe not fitting. I almost think this pair was mis-sized at the factory.

Great looking shoe but just by looking at it I could tell there was no way my foot would ever fit in it. Sad that the sizing is so off. Thank goodness for Zappo's great return policy.

I wear a size 7M. When shoes arrived I tried them on to find they were too small. My toes were at the edge of shoe. So I returned them for a size 7 1/2. When 7 1/2 arrived I also felt shoes were not true to size. Shoes are stylish but sized very small. I don't want to try again for a larger size of 8. Hopefully by wearing them in house, they will stretch out some. Will keep you inform how I made out.