Customer Reviews Clarks Janey Mae

I bought these shoes for my sister for her birthday. She loved them so much, she bought them in black.

After reading the reviews about this shoe I ordered 3 different t sizies, one smaller and one larger than my normal size. The size smaller fit snugly so I chose to keep my regular size and return the other two pairs. There was no hesitation worth zappos return snd I was notified immediately when they received the returns and gave me credit. I recommend both the shoes for co fort and style and I recommend Zappos as a great, customer oriented provider.

These are great shoes! Comfortable and stylish. I'm very happy with them.

I have a somewhat wide foot, so I usually end up buying women's shoes longer than I need just to get a little more width. These Clarks are perfect for my foot. I read other reviews that said the shoes were smaller than usual but that's just fine with me. I got a little extra width without having too much length. There is almost no padding inside the shoe but they are so comfortable. I'm a teacher so I'm on my feet all day, and the first time I wore them to work I never thought about them. I wish they came in a light tan also.

this item runs small

Great shoe! Runs a size small. Maybe narrow, but made for my thin foot, no gaps anywhere. Very good toe room Does not slip on heel. More cushioning than you see here as same sole as original wallabies but setback so not visible in picture. I have a thin foot and it is a challenge to find the right shoe. I am so happy with this shoe, I have the grey brushed leather, and I am ordering the brown smooth leather. Hopefully it will have the same fit as the grey. If not, and this is another reason why I love Zappos, back it will go. Thank you, Zappy!

I loved the style of these, and the fact that they laced. I tried a 5 (I'm usually somewhere between a 5-6), but it was very short and uncomfortable. The other sizes weren't available so I took a shot. Too bad, they're quite cute.

I wanted to love these shoes. But the right shoe feels a 1/2 size smaller than the left. I'm keeping them to see if it will stretch. Bring back the FUNNY DREAM shoes

I really like the look of these shoes, and they have been comfortable, so far. I initially tried on a size 8 and ultimately purchased a size 9, because the toe bed was too short on size 8 and 8.5. Clark's had limited inventory on these shoes, so I came to Zappos.

These shoes seemed a wee bit short for me, especially if I planned to wear heavier socks. My main reasons for returning them were that the soles had little "traction," and the shoes had no interior support of any sort.

Fun, funky shoe, and I'd have loved to keep it. I'd ordered a half size larger than normal and it was still too short. The toe box looked wide enough but was a little snug for my wide instep. And as others have noted, there is zero arch support. I wanted to love this shoe but I couldn't.

I love these shoes. I had to go up a half size and not sure if I can wear socks. But they look great at work and everyone has commented how much they like them!

I followed reviews and ordered a half-size up (typically wear a 7) and the 7.5 fit perfect. The shoes are super quirky and I love them. My only complaint is that the area around the toe-knuckle is a little stiff but I imagine it will loosen up with wear. Very satisfied and will probably order in black also.

I have these shoes in brown and love them. Ordered them in black. They look great on, but the left shoe felt just a bit short. (broke my big toe a while back and now I need lots of room in the toe box.)Had to send them back. These shoes look great on!

I received the 8.5, my usual size. The shoe is too short though and I have returned it for a 9. Beautiful shoe -nice design. I hope the 9 works.

I love these shoes even though they have very little arch support. Since I had bought a pair before of the same style, I knew to order a full size larger than I usually wear.

Cute. Wanted them to work. The sole felt too narrow for the rest of the shoe. If sole were just a little wider- would be a great shoe. Felt like my big toe was going to roll off the sole.

I used to be able to wear this style of Clarks and I loved them!! Sadly, my orthopedic issues make them hurt my feet where there is damage. However, I highly recommend these shoes and this style because they are a stylish answer to everyday footwear!

I have hard-to-fit feet (flat arches, low volume, not narrow except for heels) and I liked these shoes. I imagine that the lack of structure makes them fit a variety of feet. They are somewhat like a stiff moccasin. The width is ample for my feet across the toes and the ball of my foot. They do run a tad short for Clarks. The leather isn’t thick or very high quality like some of the other Clarks I’ve tried, but it seems adequate. It’s a bit stiff but I imagine that’s on purpose so when they are broken in, they still fit and don’t become sloppy. I liked the color and slightly luster-y finish (I ordered black and it’s a very dark gray-black rather than black-black). The sole is a thick and solid - made out of something that reminds me of rubber cement. The reason I’m returning them is because there is no arch support and the insole is not removable. I have painful plantar fasciitis and shoes with no arch support makes it worse.

Cute shoes with wider toe box. Ordered half a size up after returning the first pair. The suede softened quickly to the shape of the foot. Nice shoe for work or for casual dress.

wow these are tiny... I love the slim profile but they were small...not sure if a larger size would make a difference for me, my foot is wide and i guess thick too? the tops of my toes rubbed too much with the roof of the shoe, i tried them on without socks. i really wanted these to work for me. i'll be returning soon.

I'm a true 9.5 size but my toes were touching the end of these shoes, so it was an instant return. I didn't order another size up because I am looking for something with good arch support that I can walk in all day. These are a super cute style, but didn't address my needs. Generally, I find Clarks to be excellent shoes in the support area, so I was a bit surprised there.

Took a chance on this but it looks too much like the old "earth" shoe from the 70s with it's wide toe box. Runs small as my toes were right up to the end. a little too granola for me.

I wear a 6 usually but these run small. I exchanged for a 6.5 and still, my toes are at the very front end without socks. I love the look and feel so will try again with a size 7, going up a whole size.