Customer Reviews Columbia Heavenly Shorty Omni-Heat

The boots fit very snuggly and are tight. It’s difficult to wear thick socks with them, which are needed as these boots don’t keep my feet warm.

Fit half size too small (bought size 6), No support at all. Super cute and I might have ordered diff size but there’s this super scratchy Columbia tag thing on the upper tongue with hard creases and sharp edges. You can’t remove them and I knew those darn things rubbing against the top of my foot were a deal breaker. Ugghhh too bad, so cute and had good gripping bottoms.

Unfortunately for me, the fit was too tight and I even went up a half size! The boot was light, cute and not clunky.

I really wanted these to work. I have a different pair of Columbia boots in the same size that fit well. However, these felt very narrow. (I have wider feet but I don't usually need to buy a size wide). I recommend ordering a size up and if you have wide feet, these are not for you.

Had to return for half size larger.

Once I get my feet into these, it feels like they're shrink-wrapped onto my feet. Sadly, I have to return them.

The boots were perfect size(7.5) but too narrow. I had on Smart Wool thin wool knee highs and my feet felt squished across the top of the boot. If they made a W width they would have fit perfectly. Why boot manufacturers don't make wide widths is beyond me. Who wears a winter boot without some sort of thicker sock? I went to Boscov's and bought BareTraps ankle high boots in size 7M and they fit perfectly.

I ordered a 1/2 size bigger as was suggested by other reviewers. However, these boots still felt too small. Also they are very narrow at the toe and it doesn't feel like there is much padding in the sole. I returned them.

I was excited about wearing these bootties all winter because they looked cute and warm, but unfortunately they did not keep my feet dry or warm. After two months the fabric started ripping and cracking, which let even more dampness into the tie box! At the end of winter I had to throw these boots away because they were falling apart. Would not recommend for serious winter wear.

Was optimistic but disappointed. Looked for an "in-between" outdoor/indoor warm winter boot but should have paid more attention to previous review about it being narrow in the front and lack of arch. I am a 7-7.5M average foot so I was surprised when even the 8 felt tight. Returning and trying another brand

Had to return, no arch support, very uncomfortable, and not flattering. Zappos is as always the best.

This boot runs small and narrow. I have wide feet and generally wear a 10.5, sometimes a 10 to 10 wide, and sometimes because my feet are wide I'll have to buy a size 11 even though an 11 is usually a little too big. I ordered these in a size 11 and they were too small and narrow. They have been returned and I will not reorder. A size 11 shoe is never too small on me. So, I would recommend ordering at least a half size up if you have medium width feet and a full size up if you have wide feet. Columbia's sizing doesn't seem to be consistent. I also ordered the Columbia Loveland Mid Omni-Heat in a size 10.5 and these felt slightly bigger (while still a bit too small and narrow) than the size 11 Columbia Heavenly Shorty Omni-Heat. The furry collar on the Columbia Heavenly Shorty Omni-Heat is bulky so you would have to tuck your pants into the boot. Since these are short boots I would not recommend using them for shoveling snow.

These boots are not true to size. They run small.

IF you have narrow feet, you might love these. I have medium to wider feet and these fit like narrows to me and I put them on barefoot and the bottom is too thin - you can feel everything. Back they went.

Those boots are way too narrow and tight. Not comfortable at all. Why not offered in wide?

Really weird fit. Felt as if someone had put extra length onto the toe box - like I was wearing a clown shoe. Too bad because the boot looked good until I put it on.