Customer Reviews Columbia Heavenly Omni-Heat

I ordered half size larger and felt like it wasn’t larger. Also felt right foot was narrower. I am returning because calf height isn’t going to work for me. I prefer a taller boot for winter.

Runs small!

I liked the look of these boots, but they felt narrow in the foot. I am a solid 7 in shoes and I ordered a 7.5. They were still too small. I am returning them.

These are cute boots, comfy and waterproof. But they're not very warm despite claims. I bought them from Amazon a couple of years ago. My feet get cold in them after a 20 minute walk in 20 degrees. No toasty toes here. Disappointing. But they work for warmer weather.

So disappointed! Very, very comfortable as other reviewers said - just like having running shoes on and feel very warm, BUT.. ordered 1/2 size larger and still too small without socks and cannot exchange for larger size - I need a 9 1/2 (usually wear an 8.5, ordered 9, toes come right to end )

Should have listened to the other reviews, went a half size up and now am returning for a full size up, that may turn out to be too small too. These run VERY small, but they are stylish and once I get a pair that fits I think they'll be warm and comfy.

The boot was too narrow.

These run extremely small. I am usually an 8.5 or 9, and I ended up trying on a 10. It still felt a little tight on the instep, although the length was better (couldn't even get my foot into the 9). They are cute and a nice height, but the sizing is way off. The footbed felt more squishy than I wanted too.

I bought these last year and INITIALLY they were great. They have a higher shaft for snow protection, tongue that blocks out snow, comfortable right out of the box etc. They’re more like a sneaker fit. A minimalist shoe, zero drop with no ankle support. Actually more like an indoor around the house slipper fit. Over time they lost the minimal support they had. Also I’m a size 9 or sometimes 9.5 in boots (8.5 in sneakers) and I had to order a size 11 in these!! I’m still kinda shocked about that. Due to walking in the woods they ripped as the material isn’t meant for abrasion. They are decently warm I must say. But the MAJOR downfall is they have no grip and I’ve slipped and fell MANY times in these. Especially on concrete due to ice as well as areas of compacted snow bc there just is no grip whatsoever. These have some good qualities but for a snow boot they just don’t fit the overall bill.

I followed the advice of the other reviews and ordered 1.5 sizes bigger, but alas they were still too small. Hopefully 2 sizes bigger would work because the otherwise seem great

Bought Jan 2020 and have a hole in the bottom already. Not happy! I live in Pa so these were not even worn for at least 5 months.

This was an attractive boot, but the biggest problem was sizing both in width and length. I have many winter boots and always take the same size. These are clearly much tighter in the width and very short in the length. I even went up to an 8 and found them not comfortable to wear and had to return.

I ordered a 1/2 size larger and they feel snug, I would not even be able to wear socks with them. I would need a full size larger.

I ordered these and the Columbia Ice Maiden II in a size 12 (I'm a giant ice maiden, okay? LOL). I'm normally an 11, but ordered up based on reviews from other purchasers. The Ice Maiden style fit perfectly with my wool socks and orthotics. These felt 1-2 sizes too small, so I have to return them. I'm glad the other ones worked!

I wanted to like these. They look great. They are very light yet look like they would hold up well. Waterproof, nice tread and not clunky thick soles. Omni-Heat is so practical and worthwhile. But I wear 9s and that was the size recommendation. They are at least a half size small for me, even with normal socks. But lack of arch support is what kept me from reordering larger.

I really wanted to like these boots but they were just too small. I usually wear a size 8 but ordered an 8.5 thinking I would have room for thicker socks. Wrong. I wanted to return them for a size 9 or 9.5 but the next largest size available in any color was a 10. Too bad because they are very cute.