Customer Reviews El Naturalista Stella ND54

Super comfortable right out of the box. I wish they came in blue.

I love these shoes!!! They are very comfortable!

These are definitely beautiful but they did not fit as other El Naturalista shoes have on my feet- they were very narrow and uncomfortable and too small. I don't have a wide or otherwise unusually shaped foot. Returned.

Perfect combo of cute and comfortable. In a perfect world I'd wear a 6 or 6.5 wide, but usually have to settle for 7 med. These fit me perfectly, other than the heel on one side rubbed a bit after wearing them all day on day 1. I think it will be okay after I break them in a bit though. Not much arch support, but not a problem for me.

I absolutely love these shoes, got them in black and brown. Thinking about the red. The only thing I am concerned with is the thin soft buckle strap I hope it does not wear out from use. I would highly recommend. Work or casual you feel like your feet are in slippers and nice and cool for hot summer days.

So cute and comfy! Love this shoe. I was looking for something a little different in a black summer shoe and this fits the bill.

These are great shoes. My feet are 7.5 and I had to get size 39. So go up a size than what you normally wear. Very stylish, super comfy shoes. I usually need inserts but they seem to have a good support so I didn't need them.

I think this product should be advertised a half size down. I got a 36 advertised as 5-5½ US size, but I think it's really 5½-6. Nordstrom sells these shoes and they advertise it as 36(5½-6). Unfortunately they are a little too big and I have to return them, but they are beautiful and great quality.

These too a long time to break in and soften up the leather, so I had some issues with blisters for a bit. After that period, these are cozy!

These were incredibly comfortable but I didn’t like the brown suede . It felt a little more casual than I wanted. If they had been leather, I would have kept them. They were great for my arthritic feet. Plenty of room for the toes

They fit true to size, but, because of the pointed toe...they were too small. I didn't expect the toe to be that pointed. Otherwise, they are super cute and stylish.

Cute shoes, so hard to find closed-toe summer styles so I was hoping these would fit, but they're too narrow. I normally wear 7.5M and got the 38 -- either the width is more of a narrow, or the cut of the vamp is not right for my foot. A 39 would've been too long...

This is an attractive shoe. Comfortable enough. It’s challenging to find almond toes, but these have the flattering toe shape! It’s unique and a nice addition to my closet!

I absolutely loved the shoes and was terribly disappointed that they appeared worn when I received them. I purchased the half beige had black style and the beige part had black (dirt?) marks all over it. Also the left shoe felt a tiny bit too small for the size but given the right shoe felt ok I returned the worn looking pair and ordered a replacement in the same size. The leather is unbelievably soft so I count on it stretching to conform to the foot to at least some degree. Overall the shoes feel very comfortable so looking forward to my new pair to arrive.

These sandals are really cute but the toe bed was too shallow and small for me. I think these are built for long narrow feet.

So comfortable. Did not need to break these in at all, and I immediately started receiving compliments. My front of foot is wider than my heel, and the shoes did feel noticeably narrower at the front -- not painful, just be mindful if you have a wider foot.

I should have listened to the other reviewers and ordered a size up. The leather is soft and the shoes are pretty so I am returning the pair I bought and trying a size up (size 41 instead of my usual size 40). Hoping the next size up is not too large. As far as the colors are concerned: Tibet is a pretty red, not orange-y.

So very cute but cut into my forefoot.

I am usually size 7.5 (37-38) but I had to go up to a size 9 (40) because the top edge is quite narrow in my actual size. But the shoe has a strap so I am not floating in it. Other than the sizing issues, love the rubber sole and the overall look.

Very cute shoe! Well made and nice leather. I always wear a 7, but in this shoe, it was too small. I would suggest at least 1/2 size up if you order. I would liked to have kept them, but I would have been in pain during the wearing!

Sad to return these but the front section is just too low and a little too narrow for my pretty average 8.5 feet (I got size 39). Very pretty color and good design overall but my arch is hanging off the side of the shoe and after a short trial I can already tell my feet would be destroyed walking in these. The length seems right so sizing up wouldn't make much sense. Bummer.

Sooooo cute! But the toe box is too small and narrow, so I have to send them back. So sad that they didn't work out.

I normally wear a size 11, ordered these in 42 and they are WAAAAY too small. Seems to be the largest El Naturalista makes in women's styles too. I'm so bummed! I first saw these shoes in a store window in Rome and had to have them- it's so hard to find a closed toe summer shoe I can wear to work. These would have been amazing, they seem like top quality- sturdy, supportive, comfy, and stylish.

Fit felt true, and the support is perfect - a nice, durable, strong (yet flexible!) sole - finally !!! The toe box might cause problems if you have large bunions; they run right over that part of the foot. I LOVE the look and the comfort of these, and am looking forward to doing a lot of walking in my first (but probably not my last) pair of shoes by El Naturalista!