Customer Reviews Nine West Starship D'Orsay Flat

I thought I could convince myself to like these more, but they're just not quite right. The back of the shoe would kinda scrape up against my ankle bone when I walked with them on, and I think maybe if I wore them in, they would perhaps stop rubbing so much, but I didn't personally love the style enough to bet on not getting some pretty nasty blisters. I also just didn't really like how my toes were visible; I think they fit my foot correctly (I'm usually a 7.5 and I tried both the 7 and 7.5 (7 was too tight)), but they just weren't that flattering on me I did like the glittery design, and it's kinda laminated or glazed over, so you don't have to worry about glitter chipping off which would have been nice

I wanted SO HARD to love these, but it's clear that if you have anything but a narrow foot, this style/their cut just won't work. Cute in concept and design, but not happening. Also, the heel cuts high into tendon, much higher than any other flat I've ever had.

This is my second time purchasing these shoes. They’re my go-to! They can be dressed up or down and are perfect for the office, a party, or walking around Philly. Don’t get me wrong, we had rough beginnings. They were tough to break in, but once they were tamed, they were like butter on my feet for almost two years of consistent wearing. I’ll probably keep my old pair, even though they should probably be permanently retired... they’ve just been so good to me.

I really wanted to love this shoe. It is stylish and trendy. I got horrible blisters on the backs of my heels within 2 hours of wearing these. I was really disappointed.

100% what I hoped for. They are so cute with jeans and dresses or cropped pants. I wear them at least twice a week. They work with so many looks. Very comfortable it took a couple wears to break in the side. I will get a second pair.

Not thrilled with how fast they came apart on the heel structure. Heel structure should be firm yet my left shoe feels like that structure is broken. Also back outside part of the heel material seems to be coming apart after only a few times of wearing them.

Ouch!! I wore these shoes for an hour around my house. I ended up with a blister on both heels the size of a half dollar. They were so bad. Took two weeks to heel. All for an hour of wear. Not sure how these have four stars. They’re super cute so I’m pretty disappointed they didn’t work out. I should have read the reviews since other had the same issue. I took the four stars as a sign they were good.

I sized up from a 10 in dress shoes to a 10.5 to get a little more width. So much more comfortable this way. Could wear these all day.

After wearing these around the house, I really wanted these shoes to be part of my wardrobe. The style is great, but they were just too tight in the toe box. A wide width would fall off my heel. Pity. If you wear a narrow shoe, this would be a great addition to your shoe wardrobe.

Material feels a little like suede, very soft and smooth. Shoe fits great, would buy again in other colors!

These are so comfy and great for the spring! I received so many compliments on them and look great dressed up or down.

I LOVE these shoes! I get so many compliments on them. I treat patients all day in them without a complaint from my feet!

Very comfortable. They look better than shown. A lot better. Perfect for a day black dress for work, or any casual look.

I needed a pair of go-to black flats for professional occasions and love the D'Orsay silhouette of these shoes. These shoes are comfortable enough, but I wouldn't walk a million miles in them as the arch support is lacking a big. I'd recommend going up half a size (so glad Zappos carries these in an 11.5!).

These are perfect right out of the box, a tiny bit tight but broken in in one wearing. The leather is soft and easy on the feet. I got compliments right away. This is my second pair, the others are the nude color. I feel set for any stylish but comfortable occasion.

I ordered these in suede and while they are a tiny bit tight across the top, I am confident they with stretch to fit quickly. Very cute on, covers my toes completely & I love the pointy toe. I also have them in bone leather and they are favorites. Very comfortable and stylish.

I bought this shoe for work and interviews. It's hard to find a shoe that is a flat and looks classy enough to wear with dresses. The semi pointy toe makes this look elegant, without looking like a witch shoes. It's perfect and I'm keeping it.

These flats are very cute for those times when you need a semi-closed shoe. They looked great with long pants but also dressed up capris. The suede fabric makes them a bit dressier than leather.

Absolutely cute and more fabulous on your feet !

Beautiful shoe. Love the suede nuBuck dorsay style. I think best dorsay around. But order 1/2 size up.

For sure I thought they would be uncomfortable but they work so well for around the office. Can be worn with everything.

Love, love, love!! These are awesome. Comfortable right out of the box.. so fun to wear. Very pretty.

I have narrow feet but these fit perfectly. If my feet were a little wider, they'd still be OK. They are flexible and easy to walk in, though there is little support so I wouldn't want to shop all day in them. Going to see if they come in other colors!

I admit, I usually go for the most expensive shoe. So I ordered a few different versions of this shoe at various price ranges. This is the one I liked best, and also the most reasonably priced. It is well designed, because unlike the others it stays on my foot! I like the material, trendy yet classic black suede. And it has just the right amount of pointiness on the toe. Any less of a point would be a snub, any more would look like the perfect pair for the Wicked Witch of the West.

Fit is perfect, true to size. Comfortable on first wear.