Customer Reviews Nine West Starship D'Orsay Flat

Poorly designed—my feet would hardly fit in the toe and it cut off circulation. Nice color but impossibly to wear.

I ordered this show in size 12. I am 5'11" 148lb. The toe of this shoe is very pointy and pulls your big toe in. Not a comfortable shoe to walk in at all. Feels like it's made of wood. Even though there is no heel - this style is still foot-slavery. I will send it back :(

These shoes made my feet bleed and caused a huge blister on my heel. The material rubbed my foot raw the first time I wore them. I fixed the problem by placing moleskin along the inside of the heel and near the inner corner of the toe box were the shoe would rub me the wrong way. After that they were perfect, I get a ton of compliments when I wear them. They are super flat and have no arch support whatsoever- beware!

Cute shoe. Pinches the toes. Would have tried wider size but hubby thought they looked frumpy.

I really like the look of these flats; however, I can only wear them if I plan to do minimal walking, as they tear up my heel.

Cute and professional. I really wanted these to fit, but they aren't quite right. Rubbed under my ankle bone in the back, felt pinchy near the toes and lose in the heel.

Should have listened to reviews...will be returning. While I like the design, the shoe itself falls short. Too narrow so the outside edge of my foot hangs out. I ordered my standard 7.5 but these were pretty tight all around. There is no arch support but that seems to be the case with this style. I had also tried the Tommy Hillfiger Naree3 and while the size wasn't right for me, I would definitely pick that shoe over the NW Starship. Those were softer and had a small bit of cushion.

These shoes are super cute. Unfortunately, the toe box is really narrow and the man-made sole (at the back of the foot) caused blisters within the first 100 steps. Had to return.

This runs HUGE! I got size 5W, which I wear in another Nine West flats style, and there was a whole extra inch of space. I’ll need to return them, which is disappointing because I really like the style. If you’re getting this, you should size a full size down.

Not consistent with my size. Return process is not pandemic appropriate. I had to leave my home to drop at a UPS location.

The toe on these shoes are much more pointy than they appear in the picture. Imagine elf shoes, then longer and more pointy. Wanted to like them, returned them instead. They are seriously odd looking.

They are beautiful and look nice on but no arch support.

I really loved the style but they felt terrible... Really narrow and the back would have given me blisters if I walked anymore than just around my apartment for the few minutes I had them on. The search for cute flat continues!

I purchased these shoes about a year ago and wear them only occasionally - nonetheless, the toe is scraping off/wearing down and the shoes have somehow stretched SIGNIFICANTLY - like, I have to walk with a weird limp to even keep them on my foot, which is super disappointing. I also have a pair in the nude color and have the same problem with that pair. I like how they look on my foot, but I'm so disappointed with how badly they've worn over time.

I ordered a women size 7 and it was too small and very narrow

Not ideal shoe for people with wide feet. These shoes were so uncomfortable.

I don’t understand how these shoes have 4* overall! They are incredibly narrow (been on the stretcher for days!) and the gold material they are made of is stiff, stiff, stiff. Completely agree the heel rubs and irritates. I need these for a costume so I’m still trying to make them work!

Toes too tight

Sorry, flat-footed people (like myself!) I don't think these lovely d'orsays are for you! Unfortunately, the shape of a flat foot is not flattered by the open sides. I SO wanted them to work for my wedding, but had to go with a different shoe. A very lovely and sexy style for a medium or high-arched foot! The gold sparkles are really nice, and are covered by a clear synthetic material so that the glitter won't get everywhere.

Had to return this item. The shoe actually was a bit large and toe was pointed more than pictured.

The most uncomfortable flats I've ever worn! Back of the shoes rubs against my feet and is quite unbearable. Very poor design!

I wanted to love these shoes; they’re adorable, affordable, versatile... I’m a 7.5W (according to the quiz on Shoes of Prey’s website). I have worn a 7.5M for 18yrs with little to no issues. This shoe literally made my foot look as if it were falling out of the shoe. Horrific. Also, with all the walking I do, I doubt they’d last me 6mos.

This show was awful and Left me with blisters. I wear a 7 and these killed me.

Super cute shoes but soooo uncomfortable. I wore them twice and got blisters on my heels both times. I'm sad they do not fit better because I love the style.

These flats are so cute and stylish, which is why I tried for MONTHS to make them bearable. These are the most uncomfortable shoes I have ever owned. I have tried every trick in the book to break these shoes in and suffered through wearing them for months, but I finally had to give up. Every trick I found to break them in would make them comfortable for a couple of hours before they became uncomfortable again. The shoes are so stiff and have absolutely no give to them. It's a shame, because they look great dressed up or down.